Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Dry vs Wet Egg Cleaning: Which One Should You Buy?

Dry brushing and enzyme washing clean fresh eggs in different ways, and the right method depends on how dirty the shell is and on keeping the bloom intact.

Dry vs Wet Egg Cleaning: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Milwaukee 0880-20 18-Volt Cordless Wet/Dry VacuumMilwaukee 0880-20 18-Volt Cordless Wet/Dry VacuumView on Amazon
  2. 2Vacmaster DVOM202P 1101 2.5-Gal 20V Cordless Portable Wet/DryVacmaster DVOM202P 1101 2.5-Gal 20V Cordless Portable Wet/DryView on Amazon
  3. 3GoodEgg Enzyme Egg Wash Cleaning Solution Concentrated RefillGoodEgg Enzyme Egg Wash Cleaning Solution Concentrated RefillView on Amazon

Collecting eggs at the end of the day often means finding shells with dirt, straw and the odd smear on them, and deciding what to do about them before they reach the kitchen. For dry vs wet egg cleaning, the short answer is this: dry cleaning brushes dirt off the shell without water, while wet cleaning washes it away, and the right choice depends on how dirty the shell is and on keeping the bloom intact.

Other options for the coop

CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

Dry vs Wet Egg Cleaning: Start With the Dirt on the Shell

Eggs come out of the nest box carrying whatever the nest and the yard put on them: dirt, straw, smears and the odd caked patch. Dry cleaning takes that dirt off without water, usually with a brush or a cloth, and keeps water and solution off the shell. Wet cleaning uses water, with or without a wash solution, to wash or scrub dirt away. Neither method fits every shell: a lightly soiled shell needs little more than a brush, while a caked shell is better handled with water, which shifts what a brush leaves behind. The rest of this guide walks through both methods and the two cleaning tools in this guide.

How Dry Cleaning Works

Dry cleaning is a light touch. A brush or a cloth sweeps loose dirt, straw and dust off the shell, and the egg stays dry from start to finish. Because no water or solution touches the shell, dry cleaning does not wash the bloom away, though the brush still touches the shell. Dry cleaning suits shells that look mostly clean with a little dirt on them. It struggles where dirt is caked on or smeared, since a dry brush moves loose dirt best and may leave caked dirt behind. For those shells, water can shift what a dry brush leaves behind.

How Wet Cleaning Works

Wet cleaning adds water to the job. One route is a wash solution: the CareFree listing states its plant-based food-grade enzymes remove dirt, bacteria, fecal matter, blood, and protein residue from fresh farm eggs, and describes the wash as a gentle alternative to harsh detergents and bleach that will not damage the bloom. Another route is a brush under running water: the GoodEgg listing describes holding the egg and gently rotating it against the brush under cool water, with over 650 flexible silicone nubs sweeping the shell and ribbed edges reaching into crevices. After washing, the brush flips inside out to rinse clean, and its hollow center lets the brush drain and dry. Wet cleaning handles caked and stubborn dirt that dry brushing leaves behind, and it wets the shell in the process.

The Gear in This Guide, Ranked

First is the CareFree Enzymes egg wash. The listing states one 33.9 oz bottle makes dozens of cleaning batches, washing hundreds of fresh eggs, and suits backyard flocks of 5 to 50+ hens. Its plant-based food-grade enzymes are described as a gentle alternative to harsh detergents and bleach, with no bleach, no alcohol, no parabens and no synthetic fragrances, and the listing states the wash will not damage the bloom. The listing also states the formula has been trusted for over 30 years, uses GRAS food-grade ingredients, and is made in Kansasville, Wisconsin. For a keeper washing batches of eggs at once, a wash solution covers more shells than a single-egg brush.

Second is the GoodEgg brush. It features over 650 flexible silicone nubs, food-grade silicone, a hollow center for drainage and drying, and a dishwasher-safe build, at 1.6 ounces and 1.5 x 1.5 x 2.4 inches. The listing describes rotating the egg against the brush under cool water and flipping the brush inside out to rinse it clean. One wrinkle: the title names Large to XL sized eggs while the bullets say the brush is designed for standard-sized eggs, so check the size fit before ordering.

Which Method Fits Which Mess

Match the method to the shell in front of you. A shell with light dirt and a little straw suits dry brushing: sweep it off, check the shell, and move on. A shell with caked dirt, smears or stubborn bits suits wet cleaning: wash it with the enzyme wash, or scrub it with the brush under cool water. A shell that stays dirty after dry brushing is a wet-cleaning shell, not a sign to scrub harder dry. Keep the two methods side by side in the egg routine, and let the dirt decide which one comes out.

Keep the Bloom in Mind

The bloom is the egg’s natural cuticle coating, and the CareFree listing states its wash will not damage it. That claim is the reason to prefer a purpose-made egg wash over harsh detergents and bleach, which the listing names as the harsher alternative. Dry cleaning keeps water and solution off the shell, so it does not wash the bloom away. Whichever method is used, the goal stays the same: a clean shell with its bloom left as intact as possible.

A Simple Egg-Cleaning Routine

Gather eggs into an egg collecting basket and look over each shell. Brush light dirt off dry. Wash dirtier shells with the enzyme wash, or scrub them with the brush under cool water and rinse, then set them aside to drain and dry. Once dry, an egg skelter keeps cleaned eggs in order for kitchen use. Keep the brush rinsed and dry between uses, and keep the wash bottle where it stays handy for the next gather.

Chicken Coop Size Calculator

Birds, breed size, run time and climate in; coop floor, run space, roost length and nesting boxes out.

Open the calculator
Flock safety basics

Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

FAQ for the flock

Should fresh eggs be washed before storing?

Not every shell needs washing. Brush light dirt off dry, and wash only the shells that stay dirty, since washing wets the shell and its bloom. Clean shells can go straight to storage, while dirtier shells suit the enzyme wash or the brush under cool water.

Does washing remove the bloom?

The CareFree listing states its enzyme wash will not damage the bloom, and describes the wash as a gentle alternative to harsh detergents and bleach. Dry brushing uses no water or solution, so it does not wash the bloom away.

Can the GoodEgg brush be used without water?

The listing describes the brush for use under cool water: hold the egg, rotate it gently against the brush, and rinse under running water. It does not describe dry use, so plan on water when reaching for the brush.

What size eggs does the GoodEgg brush fit?

The title names Large to XL sized eggs, while the bullets say the brush is designed for standard-sized eggs. The two do not agree, so check the size fit before ordering.

How many eggs does one bottle of CareFree wash clean?

The listing states one 33.9 oz bottle makes dozens of cleaning batches, washing hundreds of fresh eggs, and suits backyard flocks of 5 to 50+ hens.

More coop guides

See the egg handling guides and the coop supply guides.

More buying guides