Organic vs Conventional Chicken Feed: Which One Should You Buy?
Organic and conventional chicken feed differ mainly in certification and grain sourcing on these listings, with certified organic, non-GMO and non-organic options compared by protein, form and flock stage.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Sekey Steel Garden Cart9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
PurinaView on Amazon - 3
Mile Four Organic Chicken FeedView on Amazon - 4
Scratch and Peck FeedsView on Amazon - 5
New Country OrganicsView on Amazon - 6
New Country Organics I Power Pellet Broiler Feed 40 lbs IView on Amazon - 7
Organic Non-GMO Golden Yolk Chicken Fodder Microgreens SeedsView on Amazon
For organic vs conventional chicken feed, the difference on these listings is certification and grain sourcing, not a single feed type. Certified organic listings state certified organic grains, while the non-GMO layer blend states non-GMO grains without organic certification, and none of the listings here is labeled conventional. This guide compares those listings by certification, protein, form and flock stage, so a keeper can match a bag to the birds in front of them.
Other options for the coop
PurinaCheck price on Amazon
Mile Four Organic Chicken FeedCheck price on Amazon
Scratch and Peck FeedsCheck price on Amazon
New Country OrganicsCheck price on Amazon
New Country Organics I Power Pellet Broiler Feed 40 lbs ICheck price on Amazon
Organic Non-GMO Golden Yolk Chicken Fodder Microgreens SeedsCheck price on Amazon
CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.
What organic means on these listings: organic vs conventional chicken feed
Three listings state certified organic grains. The Mile Four grower listings state that 100% of grains are certified organic and certified non-GMO, and that they are corn-free, soy-free and non-medicated. The New Country Organics layer listing states certified organic and non-GMO, and that it is corn-free and soy-free. Those statements are how the listings describe their own grain sourcing, not a separate standard explained here.
What the non-organic listing states
The Wholesome Harvest listing is the one listing here that does not state organic certification. It states a non-GMO whole grain layer blend, with cracked grains, essential oils, herbs, oyster shells and linseed oil listed as ingredients. It is described for laying hens and ducks, and it states a 16% protein blend. That makes it the closest listing here to a conventional-style layer feed, while still being non-GMO, so a keeper who does not need organic certification can compare it directly with the certified organic layer listing.
Protein, form and flock stage
Protein figures differ across these listings. The Wholesome Harvest layer blend states 16% protein, the New Country Organics layer feed states 17% protein, and both Mile Four grower listings state 18% protein. The grower listings state an age range of 8 to 20+ weeks, while the layer listings are described for laying hens, with the Wholesome Harvest listing also described for ducks. Form also differs: the Mile Four grower listings come as whole grain and as mash, the Wholesome Harvest listing states granule form, and the New Country Organics listing does not state a form in the data shown here. A feeder for mash suits the mash form.
The gear in this guide, ranked
New Country Organics Olive Oil Layer Feed: the certified organic layer option here. It states certified organic and non-GMO, corn-free and soy-free, 17% protein, olive oil as an ingredient, and a 40 pound bag, described for laying hens.
Mile Four Organic Grower Whole Grain: the certified organic grower option in whole grain form. It states certified organic and non-GMO grains, corn-free, soy-free and non-medicated, 18% protein, an age range of 8 to 20+ weeks, ingredients including alfalfa, barley, flaxseed, kelp and peas, and a 23 pound bag.
Mile Four Organic Grower Mash: the grower listing in mash form, in a smaller bag. It states certified organic and non-GMO grains, corn-free, soy-free and non-medicated, 18% protein, an age range of 8 to 20+ weeks, and a 2 pound bag, described as a sample size for finding a preferred feed type.
Wholesome Harvest Non-GMO Whole Grain Layer Blend: the non-organic layer option here. It states non-GMO cracked grains, 16% protein, essential oils, herbs, oyster shells and linseed oil, and a 40 pound bag, described for laying hens and ducks.
A simple feed checklist
- Match the feed to flock stage: layer listings for laying hens, grower listings for chickens aged 8 to 20+ weeks as stated
- Check certification on the listing: certified organic, non-GMO, or neither, as stated
- Check form: whole grain, mash or granule, where stated for each listing
- Check species: laying hens and ducks for the Wholesome Harvest listing, chicken for the other listings
- Check bag weight: 40 pounds, 23 pounds or 2 pounds, as stated for each listing
Fitting It to Your Flock
- For laying hens, compare the two layer listings by protein figure, 16% and 17% as stated, and by certification
- For growers aged 8 to 20+ weeks, compare the two Mile Four listings by form, whole grain or mash, as stated
- For a mixed flock of hens and ducks, note that only the Wholesome Harvest listing is described for ducks
- For a small trial, note the 2 pound Mile Four mash bag, described as a sample size
Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.
FAQ for the flock
What is the difference between organic and conventional feed on these listings?
On these listings, the difference is certification and grain sourcing. Certified organic listings state certified organic grains, while the Wholesome Harvest listing states non-GMO grains without organic certification, and none is labeled conventional.
What protein do these feeds state?
The Wholesome Harvest layer blend states 16% protein, the New Country Organics layer feed states 17% protein, and both Mile Four grower listings state 18% protein.
Which feed suits growers aged 8 to 20+ weeks?
Both Mile Four grower listings state that age range, one as whole grain and one as mash. The layer listings are described for laying hens, not for that grower age range.
Can laying hens and ducks eat the same feed?
Only the Wholesome Harvest listing is described for both laying hens and ducks. The other listings here are described for chickens, so check species on each listing before sharing a bag across species.
What forms are available here?
Whole grain and mash are stated for the Mile Four grower listings, granule is stated for the Wholesome Harvest listing, and no form is stated in the data shown for the New Country Organics listing. See the chicken and duck feed picks for more options.
More coop guides
- Best Chicken and Duck Feed (2026): 5 Feeds Compared
- Best Grower Feed for Chickens (2026): 5 Compared
- Best Layer Feed Pellets (2026): 5 Bags Compared
- Best Chicken Feeder for Mash (2026): 5 Top Picks Compared
- Best Chicken Feed Container Under $50 (2026)
See the coop supply guides and the feeders and waterers guides.




