Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Poly vs Steel Garden Wagon: Which One Should You Buy?

Poly and steel garden wagons for hauling feed, bedding and tools around the coop, compared by capacity, bed size, tires, handle and warranty.

Poly vs Steel Garden Wagon: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1VEVOR 1500 lbs Poly Garden Dump Cart with Convertible HandleVEVOR 1500 lbs Poly Garden Dump Cart with Convertible Handle9.5/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Gorilla Carts 600-Pound Capacity Heavy Duty Poly Yard GardenGorilla Carts 600-Pound Capacity Heavy Duty Poly Yard GardenView on Amazon
  3. 3Backyard Expressions Garden Cart and Utility WagonBackyard Expressions Garden Cart and Utility WagonView on Amazon
  4. 4HobbyField Steel Garden Cart WagonHobbyField Steel Garden Cart WagonView on Amazon
  5. 5Amazon Basics Collapsible Heavy Duty Utility Wagon forAmazon Basics Collapsible Heavy Duty Utility Wagon forView on Amazon
  6. 6Suncast 15 Gallon Poly Multipurpose Rolling Lawn and GardenSuncast 15 Gallon Poly Multipurpose Rolling Lawn and GardenView on Amazon

A wagon that hauls feed bags, bedding and tools around the coop saves trips and backs. Poly vs steel garden wagon comes down to the bed: the poly wagons here have plastic beds, while the steel wagons have mesh steel beds, and one states a rust-resistant coat. The poly side is a dump wagon and a plastic deck wagon; the steel side is a mesh cart with removable sides that turns into a flatbed.

Other options for the coop

CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

Poly vs steel garden wagon: the bed

The bed is the difference. Poly beds are plastic: the VEVOR is a poly dump wagon, and the FARM-TUFF is a plastic deck wagon. Steel beds are mesh: the VIVOHOME carts have mesh steel beds on fully-welded frames, and the 880 lb cart states a rust-resistant coating that stands up to rain, sun and scratches. The red cart’s mesh bed drains water and lets you see what you are hauling, while the poly dump wagon is built to tip its load out.

Removable sides are the steel side’s trick. The VIVOHOME carts let you take the mesh sides off and turn the cart into a flatbed trailer for larger loads. The red cart lists lumber, fence posts, tree bags or oversized loads for the flatbed. The poly wagons state no removable sides: the VEVOR is a dump wagon with a convertible handle, and the FARM-TUFF is a plastic deck wagon with pneumatic tires.

Capacity and size

Capacity splits the 4 wagons into 2 pairs. The VEVOR poly dump wagon states 1200 lb and 10 cu ft, above the steel pair at 880 and 900 lb, while the FARM-TUFF plastic deck wagon states 300 lb. The steel carts state 4.5 cu ft, so the poly VEVOR states the larger volume, and the FARM-TUFF states the smaller capacity.

Size is close across the set. The FARM-TUFF deck states 38 by 20 in, and the VIVOHOME carts list 38.1 by 20.8 in in the Size field, with a height of 21.7 in. The red cart’s Product Dimensions list 38.19 by 20.86 by 9.84 in, against 21.7 in for height in the Size field, so the 2 height figures disagree.

Tires and handle

The steel carts roll on 10 in pneumatic tires and state a 180-degree rotating handle. The red cart’s tires ship partly deflated, and the listing says to inflate them to 30 PSI before first use. The green cart’s tires are fixed by lug nuts, and its handle also tows behind a tractor, lawn mower or ATV.

The poly wagons state less about tires and handles. The FARM-TUFF states pneumatic tires and no handle, and the VEVOR states a convertible handle and no tires. The red cart states 10 in air-filled tires that roll over grass, gravel, dirt and uneven ground, while the green cart states 10 in pneumatic tires for stable rolling on grass, gravel, snow or slope.

The gear: wagons for the coop yard

The 4 wagons below start with the 2 steel carts, which carry full listings, then the 2 poly wagons, which are title-only, so their cards are short.

Wagon Bed Capacity Tires Handle Warranty
VIVOHOME 900 lb Steel Cart Mesh steel 900 lb 10 in pneumatic 180-degree, towable 1 year
VIVOHOME 880 lb Steel Cart Mesh steel 880 lb 10 in pneumatic 180-degree 1 year
VEVOR Poly Dump Wagon Poly 1200 lb Not stated Convertible Not stated
FARM-TUFF Plastic Deck Wagon Plastic deck 300 lb Pneumatic Not stated Not stated

VIVOHOME 900 lb Steel Cart

The green VIVOHOME cart states a 900 lb load capacity and 4.5 cu ft, with a fully-welded mesh steel bed, reinforced crossbars and removable sides. The 2-in-1 handle pulls by hand or tows behind a tractor, lawn mower or ATV, and it rotates 180 degrees for tight corners. The 10 in pneumatic tires are fixed by lug nuts, and the cart weighs 40.26 lb. The listing states a 1 year warranty.

One caution in the listing: for longer product life, long-term heavy loading is not recommended. The tires ship not fully inflated for safe transport.

VIVOHOME 880 lb Steel Cart

The red VIVOHOME cart states an 880 lb capacity and 4.5 cu ft, with a reinforced steel mesh bed, a fully-welded frame and removable sides that turn it into a flatbed trailer. The 10 in air-filled tires roll over grass, gravel, dirt and uneven ground, and the 180-degree rotating handle steers around flower beds, tight corners and standard garden gates. The cart weighs 38.6 lb, and the listing states a 1 year warranty.

The listing gives 2 heights: 9.84 in in Product Dimensions and 21.7 in in the Size field, so check the listing before you measure a gate. The tires ship partly deflated, and the listing says to inflate them to 30 PSI before first use.

VEVOR Poly Dump Wagon

The VEVOR is a 10 cu ft poly garden cart dump wagon with a 1200 lb capacity and a convertible handle. The listing gives only the title, so no tires, weight, bed size or warranty are stated. It is the poly pick with the larger stated capacity, and the only dump wagon here.

FARM-TUFF Plastic Deck Wagon

The FARM-TUFF is a durable plastic deck garden wagon, 38 by 20 in, with a 300 lb capacity and pneumatic tires. The listing gives only the title, so no handle, weight or warranty are stated. It is the smaller capacity pick here, for lighter loads around the coop yard.

Flock safety basics

Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

FAQ for the flock

Is poly or steel better for a garden wagon?

It depends on the job. The steel wagons here have mesh beds with removable sides for flatbed hauling, while the poly wagons are a dump wagon and a plastic deck wagon. The poly VEVOR states 1200 lb, above the steel wagons at 880 and 900 lb, so check the capacity, not just the material.

Can a garden wagon haul feed bags to the coop?

Yes. The red VIVOHOME cart states 880 lb for soil, mulch, stones, firewood and garden tools, and the green cart states 900 lb for soil bags, firewood and plants. The VEVOR states 1200 lb. A wagon that hauls feed bags, bedding and tools around the coop saves trips.

Do the steel wagons rust?

The red VIVOHOME cart states a rust-resistant coating, and its mesh bed drains water. The green VIVOHOME cart states a fully-welded mesh steel bed with no coating stated.

What size wagon fits a small yard?

The FARM-TUFF plastic deck wagon states 38 by 20 in, and the VIVOHOME carts list 38.1 by 20.8 in in the Size field. Measure the gate and the path to the coop before you buy.

Do any of these wagons state a warranty?

The VIVOHOME carts state a 1 year warranty. The VEVOR and FARM-TUFF listings state no warranty term.

More coop guides

See the coop supply guides and the garden cart for hauling chicken feed picks.

More buying guides