Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Butyl vs EPDM Pond Liner: Which One Should You Buy?

The liners in this guide are 45-mil EPDM and flexible, in sizes from 10 ft. x 15 ft. to 15 x 20 ft, with a 25-year warranty and fish-safety certification on the LifeGuard liner.

Butyl vs EPDM Pond Liner: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1LifeGuard 15 x 20 EPDM Pond LinerLifeGuard 15 x 20 EPDM Pond Liner9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2LifeGuard 20 x 20 EPDM Pond LinerLifeGuard 20 x 20 EPDM Pond Liner9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Beckett 8 x 10 PVC Pond LinerBeckett 8 x 10 PVC Pond Liner9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4VEVOR 15 x 20 ft Pond LinerVEVOR 15 x 20 ft Pond LinerView on Amazon
  5. 5ExploreHorizon 10x15 ft Pond LinerExploreHorizon 10x15 ft Pond LinerView on Amazon
  6. 6QITUO Pond Liner Seam TapeQITUO Pond Liner Seam TapeView on Amazon
  7. 7VEVOR 20 x 25 ft Pond LinerVEVOR 20 x 25 ft Pond LinerView on Amazon
  8. 8Firestone 45mil EPDM Rubber Pond Liner 15ft.x20ft.Firestone 45mil EPDM Rubber Pond Liner 15ft.x20ft.View on Amazon
  9. 9Adroiteet 14 x 14 FT Pond LinerAdroiteet 14 x 14 FT Pond LinerView on Amazon

A duck pond that holds water through the summer starts with the liner under it, and the choice usually comes down to butyl vs epdm pond liner. This guide covers the liners listed here, and every one of them is EPDM rubber, so there is no butyl liner in this guide to compare side by side. What follows is what the EPDM liners state, and how to judge a butyl liner by the same stated facts when one is listed.

Other options for the coop

CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

Butyl vs EPDM pond liner: what the liners in this guide state

The 2 liners in this guide state the same thickness, 45-mil EPDM rubber, in different sizes. The LifeGuard liner measures 10 ft. x 15 ft. and weighs 20.4 pounds, with a 25-year warranty from the maker and certification as fish and wildlife safe. The VEVOR liner measures 15 x 20 ft and weighs 79.37 pounds, and names no warranty term. The table below puts the stated facts side by side.

Liner Size Thickness Weight Warranty
LifeGuard EPDM Pond Liner (LG10X15-45) 10 ft. x 15 ft. 45-mil 20.4 pounds 25-year warranty
VEVOR EPDM Pond Liner 15 x 20 ft 45 mil 79.37 pounds Not stated

What the 45-mil EPDM liners in this guide state

LifeGuard describes its liner as durable, flexible, UV and puncture resistant, and fish and wildlife safe for koi ponds, water gardens and aquaponics systems. The maker states no plasticizers, and states that EPDM stays flexible year-round without becoming brittle over time, unlike vinyl liners. The liner lays flat and conforms easily to curves, shelves and other pond features, which suits a pond dug by hand with shelves for plants and a shallow edge for ducks to step in and out.

VEVOR describes its liner as puncture and tear-proof, flexible and pliable, easy to bend and fold for almost any pond shape, with a flat surface that reduces soil buildup and makes cleaning easier. The maker states the liner will not crack, split or deteriorate in direct sunlight, and that no tools are required for installation. It suits water gardens, waterfalls, outdoor ponds, fish and koi ponds, and planting beds, and the liner can even be extended for use in self-watering projects.

How to judge a butyl liner by the same facts

A butyl liner earns its place the same way: by what the maker states. Check the stated thickness in mil first, since the liners here state 45-mil, then look for a fish-safety certification in the maker’s own words, a warranty term in years, and a stated size that covers the pond with room to spare. A liner that states none of those facts leaves the keeper guessing, whatever the material name on the label. When a butyl liner is listed, run it through the same checks and compare it with the EPDM liners here on stated facts alone.

Sizing the liner to the pond

VEVOR advises determining the pond’s precise depth and width before buying, and buying a liner slightly larger than the pond, since any excess liner can be cut off after installation. LifeGuard lays flat and conforms to curves and shelves, so measure the pond’s depth and width and allow for the shelves. The pond liner calculator runs the size for a pond shape.

Where the 2 liners fit

LifeGuard names koi ponds, water gardens, aquaponics systems, waterfalls, streambeds, fish hatcheries and retention basins, and states certification as fish and wildlife safe, with koi, turtles and aquatic life named. VEVOR names water gardens, waterfalls, outdoor ponds, fish and koi ponds, planting beds and self-watering projects. For a duck pond, the LifeGuard liner carries the stated certification, while the VEVOR liner covers the larger size at 15 x 20 ft.

Flock safety basics

Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

FAQ for the flock

Is EPDM pond liner safe for ducks and fish?

The LifeGuard liner is certified fish and wildlife safe, and the maker names koi, turtles and aquatic life. The VEVOR liner is made for fish or koi ponds. For ducks, look for the same fish-safety certification in the maker’s own words before buying.

What thickness are the liners in this guide?

The liners in this guide state 45-mil thickness, the LifeGuard at 10 ft. x 15 ft. and the VEVOR at 15 x 20 ft. Thickness in mil is the first figure to compare when a butyl liner is listed.

How long is the warranty on the LifeGuard liner?

The maker states a 25-year manufacturer’s warranty. The fish and wildlife safety certification is from Guardian Systems Inc. The VEVOR liner names no warranty term.

Can you cut a pond liner to fit?

For the VEVOR liner, yes. The maker states that any excess liner can be cut off after installation, and advises buying a liner slightly larger than the pond. Measure the pond’s precise depth and width first, then trim the excess.

Do EPDM liners stay flexible in cold weather?

LifeGuard states its EPDM liner stays flexible year-round without becoming brittle over time, unlike vinyl liners. That flexibility is what lets the LifeGuard liner conform to curves and shelves during installation.

More coop guides

See the best pond liners picks, compare EPDM vs PVC pond liner, or run the pond liner calculator for the pond size.

More buying guides