Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Egg Crates vs Egg Cartons: Which One Should You Buy?

Egg crates vs egg cartons: what each one is, when to use which, and 12-count cartons compared for the fridge and the market stall.

Egg Crates vs Egg Cartons: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1EVANCENT 100 Pack Large Egg CartonsEVANCENT 100 Pack Large Egg Cartons9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 240 Pack Half Dozen Egg Cartons Bulk 6 Count40 Pack Half Dozen Egg Cartons Bulk 6 Count9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 360 PCS Plastic Egg Cartons Bulk with Date Labels60 PCS Plastic Egg Cartons Bulk with Date Labels9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Economy Egg Cartons BulkEconomy Egg Cartons BulkView on Amazon
  5. 5Estune 120 Pack Egg Cartons Crates 30 Cell Pulp Fiber EggEstune 120 Pack Egg Cartons Crates 30 Cell Pulp Fiber EggView on Amazon
  6. 6120 Pack Egg Cartons Cheap Bulk120 Pack Egg Cartons Cheap BulkView on Amazon
  7. 7Ccuiicy 15 Pack Egg Cartons BulkCcuiicy 15 Pack Egg Cartons BulkView on Amazon
  8. 8Hatortempt 48pc Egg Cartons Cheap Bulk 12 CountHatortempt 48pc Egg Cartons Cheap Bulk 12 CountView on Amazon
  9. 9Hatortempt 24pc Egg Cartons Cheap Bulk 12 CountHatortempt 24pc Egg Cartons Cheap Bulk 12 CountView on Amazon

The basket is full of warm eggs and the market stall opens in an hour, so the eggs need something to ride in. Egg crates vs egg cartons comes down to this: a carton is the lidded box that holds a dozen eggs for the fridge or the market table, while a crate is a bigger carrier that holds stacked cartons or loose trays. This guide explains the difference, then compares cartons you can buy in bulk.

Other options for the coop

CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

Egg crates vs egg cartons: what is the difference

A carton holds a dozen eggs in its own cells under a lid, so each egg sits apart from the next and the lid keeps the eggs covered. A crate is a larger carrier that holds cartons or trays in stacks, and the open kind has no lid of its own. Cartons suit selling by the dozen at a market stall or storing eggs in the fridge, while crates suit moving a larger number of eggs from the coop to the packing table. The cartons below all hold 12 eggs, and they differ in material, pack size and what comes in the box. See our best egg collecting basket guide for the basket that carries the eggs from the nest box to the table.

Clear plastic or paper pulp

Clear plastic shows the eggs without opening the lid. The WIKDAY carton states food-grade PP plastic with anti-crack edges, and the DecarDamai carton states recycled PET plastic that can be washed and reused many times. Paper pulp cannot be seen through. The CINPIUK listing says its pulp cartons need to stay dry to be reused, and the maker calls the CINPIUK pulp biodegradable. Pulp suits a carton that goes home with the buyer, while clear plastic suits a fridge shelf where you want to see the eggs.

The cartons to compare

The WIKDAY carton is a clear 12-count carton in food-grade PP plastic, sold as a 100-pack with date stickers and an egg care guide in the box. The 2×6 grid holds medium eggs, the clear walls show the eggs and the dates, and the stackable design is what the maker claims saves 60% of fridge or shelf space. It measures 4.0 x 11.0 x 2.8 in.

The DecarDamai carton is a clear 12-count carton in recycled PET plastic, sold as a 100-pack with a 3×4 layout. It holds 12 chicken eggs of 42-72g, with tight closure buttons and cone supports to keep the eggs steady, and the flat top stacks for displays. It measures 7.8 x 5.7 x 2.8 in, and the cartons can be washed and reused many times.

The CINPIUK carton is a paper pulp 12-count carton in a 3×4 layout, sold as a 50-pack with a printed Farm Fresh, Hand Gathered and Free Range design. The recycled pulp is what the maker calls biodegradable, the trays stack in a standard 12-egg size, and the cartons can be reused multiple times if kept dry. No dimensions are stated.

The Dubtnion carton is a paper pulp 12-count carton in a 3×4 layout, sold as a 25-pack with a front clasp and interior pillars. The blank top leaves room to write the date or the egg type, and the cartons stack for the fridge or pantry. The listing gives dimension figures that do not match: 3 x 6.5 x 7.7 in in the bullets and 7.7 x 3 x 3 in in the size field. Trust the bullets until the maker clears it up.

What to check before you buy in bulk

Start with the pack size. The cartons here come in packs of 100, 50 and 25, so match the pack to how many dozen you sell or store. Check the dimensions against the fridge shelf or the market box, and check the grid: the WIKDAY carton uses a 2×6 grid, and the rest use a 3×4 grid. Check what comes in the box, since only the WIKDAY pack states date stickers and a guide. Check the material as well: clear plastic shows the eggs, and the CINPIUK pulp needs to stay dry to be reused. If the listing gives no dimensions, measure a carton you already own before you order in bulk.

Flock safety basics

Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

Fitting It to Your Flock

  • A 100-pack of clear cartons suits a keeper who sells by the dozen and wants to see the eggs.
  • Paper pulp suits a market stall where the carton goes home with the buyer.
  • Keep the CINPIUK pulp cartons dry, since the listing says they can be reused only if kept dry.
  • Use the date stickers in the WIKDAY pack to track which eggs came in first.

FAQ for the flock

What is the difference between an egg crate and an egg carton?

A carton is a lidded box that holds a dozen eggs in cells, while a crate is a larger carrier that holds cartons or trays in stacks. Cartons suit selling by the dozen, and crates suit moving a larger number of eggs at once.

How many eggs does each carton hold?

Each carton here holds 12 eggs. The WIKDAY carton uses a 2×6 grid, and the rest use a 3×4 grid.

Can paper pulp cartons be reused?

The CINPIUK listing says its cartons can be reused multiple times if kept dry, and the Dubtnion listing says its cartons can be used over and over again, with pulp that can absorb humidity. Keep the CINPIUK cartons dry for reuse.

Are clear plastic cartons better than pulp cartons?

It depends on the job. Clear cartons let you see the eggs, and the DecarDamai clear cartons can be washed and reused many times, while the CINPIUK pulp cartons go home with the buyer and the maker calls that pulp biodegradable. Pick clear for the fridge and pulp for cartons that go home with the buyer.

Do egg cartons need to be food-grade?

Eggs sit in the carton, so the material matters. The WIKDAY carton states food-grade PP plastic. The other cartons state recycled paper pulp or recycled PET plastic, so read the listing before you buy.

More coop guides

See the best chicken nesting box guide and the best egg cartons for farmers market guide.

More buying guides