Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Glass vs Plastic Pickled Egg Jar: Which One Should You Buy?

Glass keeps pickled egg brine clean and easy to reach, and this guide ranks four glass jars by size, lid and mouth to help you pick the right one.

Glass vs Plastic Pickled Egg Jar: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Ball Wide Mouth Glass Mason Jars with Lids and BandsBall Wide Mouth Glass Mason Jars with Lids and BandsView on Amazon
  2. 2kitchentoolz Half Gallon Glass Large Mason Jar Wide Mouthkitchentoolz Half Gallon Glass Large Mason Jar Wide MouthView on Amazon
  3. 3kitchentoolz 1 Gallon Glass Mason Jar with Airtight Lid forkitchentoolz 1 Gallon Glass Mason Jar with Airtight Lid forView on Amazon
  4. 4kitchentoolz Large 1 Gallon Glass Mason Jar Extra Wide-Mouthkitchentoolz Large 1 Gallon Glass Mason Jar Extra Wide-MouthView on Amazon
  5. 5North Mountain Supply 1/2 Gallon Glass Jar Wide Mouth withNorth Mountain Supply 1/2 Gallon Glass Jar Wide Mouth withView on Amazon

A batch of peeled eggs waits on the counter with the brine mixed, and the only question left is what to put it all in. For a glass vs plastic pickled egg jar, glass is the pick: three of the four makers list BPA-free glass, and one maker states that glass helps prevent flavor absorption. Every jar in the gear section below is glass, because no plastic jar appears in the set of jars this guide covers, so the plastic side is judged on the plastic lids the makers list.

Other options for the coop

This guide covers the material, the size and the lid, then ranks the four glass jars, so the jar you pick matches the batch.

CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

Glass vs plastic pickled egg jar: start with the material

A pickled egg jar holds brine around the eggs, so the jar body does the work. The makers list glass bodies for all four jars, with BPA-free glass stated for the North Mountain Supply, kitchentoolz and FastRack jars. North Mountain Supply lists food-grade glass, kitchentoolz lists a BPA-free glass jar with lid, and FastRack lists food-grade glass that is BPA-free and lead-free. North Mountain Supply also states that food-grade glass helps prevent flavor absorption: the brine seasons the eggs, not the jar.

Plastic still has a place in this guide, just not as the jar body. North Mountain Supply fits a black plastic lid, and FastRack fits a reusable plastic cap that the maker says will not rust over time. kitchentoolz takes the other route with a BPA-free metal cap lined for a tight seal. For the jar itself, glass is the pick, and for the lid the FastRack plastic cap will not rust, while the kitchentoolz metal cap has an airtight seal. Mason jars do other coop jobs too, and the mason jar waterer comparison looks at one of them.

Pick a size that fits the batch

Jar size decides how many eggs one batch holds and how much shelf space the jar takes. The gallon jars here, from North Mountain Supply and FastRack, suit a large batch, and North Mountain Supply lists its jar at 128 ounces. The kitchentoolz jar is a half gallon at 64 ounces, a middle size for a modest batch. The Ball jars are quart size at 32 ounces and come as a pack of two, so each small batch has its own jar. Eggs for pickling come from the flock, and the fresh egg care guide covers washing and storage before the eggs reach the jar.

A bigger jar also takes more room: the North Mountain Supply jar measures 10.5 inches by 10.5 inches by 6.0 inches, and the FastRack jar measures 12.0 inches by 7.0 inches by 7.0 inches, so check the shelf before ordering.

The gear: four glass jars, ranked

The four jars are ranked below, with the strongest all-round pick first.

1. North Mountain Supply 1 Gallon Wide-Mouth Glass Jar with Lid

The maker lists a 1 gallon jar at 128 ounces with a wide mouth, BPA-free food-grade glass and a black plastic lid, and the listing names pickled eggs among its uses. The wide opening gives easy access for filling, emptying and cleaning, and the maker states that the glass helps prevent flavor absorption. It is made in the USA and measures 10.5 inches by 10.5 inches by 6.0 inches. Who it suits: keepers pickling a large batch who want a wide mouth. Who should skip it: keepers who want a small jar or a metal lid.

Pros:

  • 1-gallon size at 128 ounces for a large batch
  • Wide mouth for easy filling, emptying and cleaning
  • BPA-free food-grade glass that helps prevent flavor absorption
  • Made in the USA

Cons:

  • The lid is black plastic, not glass or metal
  • The maker does not state dishwasher safety
  • Sold as a single jar
  • No warranty term is stated

2. FastRack 1 Gallon Glass Jar with Lid

The FastRack jar is the other gallon pick, and its lid is its strong point. The maker lists a 1-gallon clear glass jar with a plastic screw-on lid, food-grade glass that is BPA-free and lead-free, and a wide mouth for easy filling and cleaning. The lid is made to keep dust out, and unlike metal lids it will not rust over time, in the maker’s words. It weighs 2.0 pounds and measures 12.0 inches by 7.0 inches by 7.0 inches. Who it suits: keepers who want a gallon jar and a lid that will not rust. Who should skip it: keepers short on tall shelf space.

Pros:

  • 1-gallon capacity for a large batch
  • Food-grade glass that is BPA-free and lead-free
  • Plastic screw-on lid that will not rust
  • Wide mouth for easy filling, cleaning and access

Cons:

  • It weighs 2.0 pounds
  • At 12.0 inches tall it needs tall shelf space
  • Sold as a single jar
  • The maker does not state dishwasher safety

3. kitchentoolz Half Gallon Glass Mason Jar with Airtight Metal Lid

The kitchentoolz jar is the middle size, and its mouth is its strong point. The maker lists a half gallon jar at 64 ounces with a wide 110mm opening, against standard 86mm jars, that fits a measuring cup, scoop, or a whole hand. The BPA-free metal cap is lined for a tight seal, the thick clear glass is dishwasher safe, and the jar is made in the USA, at 5.59 inches by 5.59 inches by 6.28 inches. Who it suits: keepers pickling a modest batch who want to reach in easily. Who should skip it: keepers who need a gallon jar.

Pros:

  • Wide 110mm mouth opening that fits a measuring cup, scoop, or hand
  • BPA-free metal cap with an airtight seal
  • Dishwasher safe thick clear glass
  • Made in the USA

Cons:

  • At 64 ounces it holds a smaller batch than the gallon jars here
  • Sold as a single jar
  • Only one lid comes with the jar
  • The maker does not state a rust-free claim for the metal cap

4. Ball Wide Mouth Glass Mason Jars with Lids and Bands

The Ball jars are the small-batch pick, and the pack is the point: two quart jars at 32 ounces each, with lids and bands, for canning, pickling, juice, jam and jelly. The wide mouth suits filling and cleaning, and the pair covers two batches at once. The maker lists the jars at 5.5 inches by 2.7 inches by 2.7 inches and the item weight at 0.58 pounds. Who it suits: keepers pickling a small batch, or two batches at once. Who should skip it: keepers who want one large jar.

Pros:

  • Pack of two quart jars at 32 ounces each
  • Wide mouth with lids and bands included
  • Quart size suits a small batch
  • Stated for canning and pickling

Cons:

  • 32 ounces is the smallest size in this guide
  • Two small jars mean more lids to manage than one large jar
  • The maker does not state dishwasher safety
  • The maker does not state BPA-free glass for this jar

What to check before you order

  • Match the size to the batch: a quart, a half gallon, or a gallon
  • Look at the lid: the FastRack plastic cap will not rust, and the kitchentoolz metal cap is BPA-free with an airtight seal
  • Check the mouth: the kitchentoolz jar lists a 110mm opening
  • Check the shelf: the tallest jar here measures 12.0 inches
  • Check the care: only the kitchentoolz jar states dishwasher safety
Backyard Egg Cost Calculator

What a dozen of your own eggs really costs, with and without startup costs, against the store price.

Open the calculator
Flock safety basics

Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

FAQ for the flock

Can a plastic jar hold pickled eggs?

The four jars in this guide are all glass, and no plastic jar is featured. BPA-free glass is stated for the North Mountain Supply, kitchentoolz and FastRack jars, and plastic appears as lid material: the FastRack lid will not rust, and the North Mountain Supply jar has a black plastic lid.

What size jar suits pickled eggs?

Match the jar to the batch. A quart jar at 32 ounces suits a small batch, a half gallon jar at 64 ounces suits a modest batch, and a gallon jar suits a large batch. The Ball pack gives two quart jars, so two small batches have a jar each.

Does a pickled egg jar need a wide mouth?

Every jar in this guide has a wide mouth. North Mountain Supply, kitchentoolz and FastRack state that the wide mouth makes filling and cleaning easy. The kitchentoolz jar lists a 110mm opening that fits a measuring cup, scoop, or a whole hand, against standard 86mm jars.

Is a metal lid or a plastic lid better for pickled eggs?

Both are listed here. The FastRack plastic lid will not rust over time, and the kitchentoolz metal cap is BPA-free with an airtight seal. The North Mountain Supply jar comes with a black plastic lid.

Can a pickled egg jar go in the dishwasher?

Only the kitchentoolz jar states dishwasher safety. The makers of the other jars do not state it.

More coop guides

See the egg handling picks and the coop supply guides.

More buying guides