Pellets vs Crumbles for Chickens: Which One Should You Buy?
Pellets and crumbles compared as layer feed forms, with protein levels, bag sizes and feeding directions from four current listings.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
PurinaView on Amazon - 2
Mile Four Organic Chicken FeedView on Amazon - 3
All Flock Feed PelletsView on Amazon - 4
Waggin' Train Layena Chicken FeedView on Amazon - 5
Small Pet Select Chicken Layer Feed PelletsView on Amazon - 6
Country Heritage 10LB Hen Egg Layer Pellet Chicken FeedView on Amazon
At morning feeding time, the scoop comes out and the flock gathers at the feeder, and the question on many keepers minds is pellets vs crumbles for chickens. For laying hens, pellets and crumbles are forms of layer feed. Three listings describe themselves as complete feed, while the Purina listing does not use the word complete, so the shared ground is the laying-hen job, not an identical claim on every listing. The Manna Pro listing describes its crumbles as a form for easy pecking, while the pellet listings describe a pelleted form, so the choice comes down to form, ingredients, bag size and the ages each listing names.
Other options for the coop
PurinaCheck price on Amazon
Mile Four Organic Chicken FeedCheck price on Amazon
All Flock Feed PelletsCheck price on Amazon
Waggin' Train Layena Chicken FeedCheck price on Amazon
Small Pet Select Chicken Layer Feed PelletsCheck price on Amazon
Country Heritage 10LB Hen Egg Layer Pellet Chicken FeedCheck price on Amazon
CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.
Pellets vs crumbles for chickens: the short answer
Pellets and crumbles are different shapes of layer feed, and the four listings in this guide show three pellets and one crumbles, all sold as feed for laying hens. Three of the four listings state 16% protein, while the fourth states no protein percentage. That shared figure applies only to the three listings that state it, and the listings differ in ingredients, so form is one difference between them, not the only one.
Waste is the other point both sides raise. The Manna Pro crumbles listing says its crumbles encourage easy pecking and reduce waste, while the CountryMax pellets listing says its pelleted form reduces waste compared to mash formulations. Neither listing compares pellets against crumbles directly, so a keeper cannot settle the waste question from these listings alone. Bag size and starting age give firmer ground: bags run from 8 lb to 50 lb, and starting ages run from 16 weeks to 20 weeks or when laying begins.
What pellets offer
Three of the four listings are pellets. Purina Layena Pellets come in a 50 lb bag for adult laying hens, with added marigold extract, calcium, manganese and trace minerals, lysine and methionine, vitamins A, D and E, and prebiotics, probiotics and yeast listed. The listing also names oyster shell as a calcium source. Scratch and Peck Layer Pellets come in a 25 lb bag at 16% protein, described as corn and soy free, certified organic and Non-GMO Project Verified, with GRUB protein from black soldier fly larvae listed among the ingredients. That listing is for laying chickens and ducks from 20 weeks of age or when laying begins, and it notes recyclable and compostable packaging and milling in the USA and Canada.
Country Heritage Layer Pellets come in a 50 lb bag at 16% protein, with 2.5% fat and 8% fiber stated. The listing covers laying chickens from 16 weeks through productive life, fed as a sole ration, and it directs keepers to provide access to oyster shell or limestone if needed, to always provide clean water, and to store the feed in a cool, dry location away from insects, rodents and pests. It also says not to feed the product if mold is present. The listing names the feed as made in the USA.
What crumbles offer
The single crumbles listing is Manna Pro Layer Crumbles, an 8 lb bag at 16% protein for laying hens. Its bullets describe a crumble form for easy digestion and feeding, with crumbles that encourage easy pecking and reduce waste, plus probiotics, vitamins and minerals including calcium listed. The spec table lists all life stages and small breeds under breed recommendation, and the listing states no added antibiotics. That spec-table age range conflicts with the listing’s own description as feed for laying hens, so it should not be taken as a recommendation for birds of every age. The small bag is the clearest practical difference from the pellet listings: it suits a keeper who wants to try a crumble form without committing to a large bag.
How to choose between pellets and crumbles
Start with the ages each listing names. CountryMax starts at 16 weeks, Scratch and Peck starts at 20 weeks or when laying begins, Purina lists adult birds, and Manna Pro lists all life stages. A flock that has not started laying fits the CountryMax age range on paper, since that listing starts at 16 weeks. Manna Pro does not fit that reading: its spec table lists all life stages, but its title and bullets describe it as feed for laying hens, so the listing itself is conflicting on age and should not be read as a fit for birds that have not started laying. A flock already laying fits any of the four listings as described for laying hens. Then weigh bag size against storage: an 8 lb bag is easy to store and finish, while 25 lb and 50 lb bags suit a larger flock or a longer stretch between orders. The cool, dry storage direction comes from the CountryMax listing only; the other listings do not state storage directions here.
Form is the last decider, and it is the least settled by these listings. The Manna Pro crumbles listing describes its crumbles as easy to peck, and the CountryMax pellets listing says its pelleted form reduces waste against mash, and neither listing measures one form against the other. A keeper switching forms can watch the feeder over a few days and see which form the flock finishes with less scattered feed. Oyster shell appears in three listings: Scratch and Peck mentions free choice oyster shell alongside its layer feed, CountryMax directs keepers to provide access to oyster shell or limestone if needed, and Purina names oyster shell as a calcium source.
The feeds in this guide
Ranked first is Scratch and Peck Layer Pellets, a 25 lb bag at 16% protein, certified organic and Non-GMO Project Verified, corn and soy free, with GRUB protein listed, for laying chickens and ducks from 20 weeks of age or when laying begins. Its listing gives the fullest picture of ingredients and sourcing, including recyclable and compostable packaging and milling in the USA and Canada.
Second is Country Heritage Layer Pellets, a 50 lb bag at 16% protein with 2.5% fat and 8% fiber, for laying chickens from 16 weeks through productive life as a sole ration. Its listing gives the fullest feeding directions, including oyster shell or limestone if needed, clean water, cool and dry storage, and not feeding if mold is present.
Third is Purina Layena Pellets, a 50 lb bag for adult laying hens, listing added marigold extract, calcium, manganese and trace minerals, lysine and methionine, vitamins A, D and E, and prebiotics, probiotics and yeast, with oyster shell named as a calcium source. It states no protein percentage, which keeps it behind the two listings that state 16% protein.
Fourth is Manna Pro Layer Crumbles, an 8 lb bag at 16% protein, the only crumbles form in this guide. Its listing describes a crumble form for easy pecking, with probiotics, vitamins and minerals including calcium listed, all life stages in the spec table, and no added antibiotics stated. It ranks last on bag size and detail rather than on form: the listing says less about sourcing and directions than the pellet listings do.
How much feed your flock eats a day and a month, how long a bag lasts, and what it costs.
Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.
FAQ for the flock
Do pellets and crumbles differ in protein?
Among the listings that state a protein figure, no: Manna Pro, Scratch and Peck and CountryMax all state 16% protein. Purina states no protein percentage, so protein cannot be compared for that listing, and the protein question cannot be settled for all four listings.
Which form wastes less feed?
These listings do not settle it. Manna Pro says its crumbles reduce waste, and CountryMax says its pelleted form reduces waste compared to mash, but neither listing compares pellets against crumbles directly.
At what age do these feeds start?
CountryMax starts at 16 weeks, Scratch and Peck starts at 20 weeks or when laying begins, Purina lists adult birds, and Manna Pro’s spec table lists all life stages, although its title and bullets describe it as feed for laying hens, so that listing is conflicting on age.
What bag sizes are available?
Manna Pro comes in an 8 lb bag, Scratch and Peck in a 25 lb bag, and Purina and CountryMax in 50 lb bags.
Do any listings mention oyster shell?
Yes. Scratch and Peck mentions free choice oyster shell alongside its layer feed, and CountryMax directs keepers to provide access to oyster shell or limestone if needed. Purina names oyster shell as a calcium source.
More coop guides
- Best Layer Feed Pellets (2026): 5 Bags Compared
- Best Chicken Feeder for Mash (2026): 5 Top Picks Compared
- Best Chicken Feeder No Waste: Picks That Save Feed
- Best Hanging Chicken Feeder (2026): 5 Top Picks Compared
See the feeder and waterer guides and the layer feed pellets guide.




