Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Mash vs Crumbles Chicken Feed: Which One Should You Buy?

Mash and crumbles chicken feed compared by form, stated protein, bag size and fermenting, with two examples on each side.

Mash vs Crumbles Chicken Feed: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Scratch and Peck Feeds Grower CrumblesScratch and Peck Feeds Grower Crumbles9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Scratch and Peck Feeds Starter Mash for ChickensScratch and Peck Feeds Starter Mash for Chickens9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Scratch and Peck Feeds Layer Crumbles for ChickensScratch and Peck Feeds Layer Crumbles for Chickens9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Scratch and Peck Feeds Grower Mash for ChickensScratch and Peck Feeds Grower Mash for Chickens9.5/10View on Amazon

Mash vs crumbles chicken feed verdict: Choose mash if you want loose whole grains and the option to ferment, which both mash examples here state. Choose crumbles if you want whole grains formed into pieces, in the larger bags the two crumble examples here use.

Filling the feeder on the morning round, you can watch the flock pick through loose grains piece by piece, or peck at formed crumbles that all look the same. That texture choice is the heart of mash vs crumbles chicken feed. This comparison covers the two forms, then four examples from one maker, two on each side.

CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

Four examples

Scratch and Peck Feeds Grower Crumbles

Scratch and Peck Feeds Grower Crumbles

Scratch and Peck Feeds9.6/10 Keeper Score
i
The Keeper Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

Whole grain grower crumbles for chickens and ducks, stated at 17% protein, corn and soy free, in a 25 lb bag.

The Grower Crumbles example is a whole grain grower feed for chickens and ducks with stated protein of 17%. The maker states the whole grains are formed into convenient crumbles, with no fillers or medications, and USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified certifications. The bag size is 25 lb.

Pros

  • 25 lb bag, the larger size here
  • 17% stated protein for the grower stage
  • Whole grains formed into crumbles
  • No fillers or medications, as stated by the maker

Cons

  • Grower stage only, not a layer feed
  • Crumbles only, no loose whole grain mash in the bag
  • 25 lb bag is heavy to carry to the coop
  • Protein stated at 17%, below the 20.5% starter mash
Scratch and Peck Feeds Starter Mash for Chickens

Scratch and Peck Feeds Starter Mash for Chickens

Scratch and Peck Feeds9.6/10 Keeper Score
i
The Keeper Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

Fermentable starter mash for chicks and ducklings, stated at 20.5% protein, corn and soy free, in a 10 lb pouch.

The Starter Mash example is a fermentable starter feed for chicks and ducklings with stated protein of 20.5% from organic grains. The maker states it can be served dry or fermented, and that it is crafted without unnecessary additives. Certified Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified certifications are stated, in a 10 lb pouch with recyclable and compostable packaging.

Pros

  • Highest stated protein here at 20.5%
  • Can be served dry or fermented, per the maker
  • Corn and soy free, as stated
  • Recyclable and compostable packaging stated

Cons

  • 10 lb pouch, smaller than the 25 lb crumble bags
  • No warranty term is stated
  • Starter stage only, a grower feed follows later
  • Fermenting adds a daily chore if you choose that option
Scratch and Peck Feeds Layer Crumbles for Chickens

Scratch and Peck Feeds Layer Crumbles for Chickens

Scratch and Peck Feeds9.6/10 Keeper Score
i
The Keeper Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

Layer crumbles for laying chickens and ducks, stated at 16% protein, corn and soy free, in a 25 lb bag.

The Layer Crumbles example is a layer feed for laying chickens and ducks with stated protein of 16% from organic grains. The maker states the crumbles are easy to peck for both small and large beaks, with no unnecessary additives. Certified Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified certifications are stated, in a 25 lb bag with recyclable and compostable packaging.

Pros

  • 25 lb bag, the larger size here
  • Made for laying chickens and ducks, as stated
  • Easy to peck for small and large beaks, per the maker
  • Recyclable and compostable packaging stated

Cons

  • Lowest stated protein here at 16%
  • Layer stage only, not a starter or grower feed
  • Crumbles only, no loose whole grain mash in the bag
  • 25 lb bag is heavy to carry to the coop
Scratch and Peck Feeds Grower Mash for Chickens

Scratch and Peck Feeds Grower Mash for Chickens

Scratch and Peck Feeds9.5/10 Keeper Score
i
The Keeper Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

Fermentable whole grain grower mash for chickens and ducks, stated at 17% protein, corn and soy free, in a 10 lb pouch.

The Grower Mash example is a whole grain grower feed for chickens and ducks with stated protein of 17%. The maker states it is fermentable, corn-free and soy-free, with USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified certifications and no fillers or medications. The pouch size is 10 lb.

Pros

  • Fermentable whole grains, stated by the maker
  • 17% stated protein for the grower stage
  • Corn and soy free, as stated
  • USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified stated

Cons

  • 10 lb pouch, smaller than the 25 lb crumble bags
  • No warranty term is stated
  • Grower stage only, not a layer feed
  • Whole grains are loose in the pouch, not formed into crumbles

Other options for the coop

Mash vs crumbles chicken feed: side by side

Factor Starter Mash Grower Mash Grower Crumbles Layer Crumbles
Form Mash Mash Crumbles Crumbles
Stage Starter Grower Grower Layer
Protein (stated) 20.5% 17% 17% 16%
Bag size 10 lb pouch 10 lb pouch 25 lb bag 25 lb bag
Fermenting Stated fermentable Stated fermentable Not stated Not stated
Corn and soy Stated free Stated free Stated free Stated free
Packaging Recyclable and compostable Not stated Not stated Recyclable and compostable

These figures are the coop makers’ own ratings, read from each listing on 19 November 2026.

What mash and crumbles are

The difference is form, not the grain itself. The Grower Mash example describes whole grains you can see individually in the pouch. The Grower Crumbles example describes whole grains and other ingredients formed into convenient crumbles. So the mash examples here arrive as loose whole grains, and the crumble examples arrive as whole grains formed into small pieces. Both forms here are stated corn and soy free, and both sides state USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified certifications.

Protein and life stage

Each example names a life stage and a protein figure. On the mash side, the Starter Mash example states 20.5% protein and the Grower Mash example states 17% protein. On the crumble side, the Grower Crumbles example states 17% protein and the Layer Crumbles example states 16% protein. The stage name on the bag, starter, grower or layer, is the maker stated guide to which birds the bag is made for. All four examples are stated for chickens and ducks.

Fermenting and serving

Fermenting is stated only on the mash side. Both mash examples are described as fermentable, and the Starter Mash example states it can be served dry or fermented. Neither crumble example states a fermenting option. The Layer Crumbles example is described as easy to peck for both small and large beaks. If fermenting is part of your routine, the mash examples here are the ones that state it; our fermented vs dry chicken feed guide covers that choice on its own.

Bag size and packaging

Bag size separates the examples cleanly. Both mash examples come in a 10 lb pouch, and both crumble examples come in a 25 lb bag. A 25 lb bag means fewer trips to refill the feed bin and more weight to carry to the coop, while a 10 lb pouch is lighter to handle and store. The Starter Mash and Layer Crumbles examples state recyclable and compostable packaging. For storage questions, see does chicken feed go bad.

Certifications and ingredients

All four examples state USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified certifications, and all four state corn and soy free recipes. The Grower Mash and Grower Crumbles examples also state no fillers or medications. The Starter Mash example states it is crafted without unnecessary additives, and the Layer Crumbles example states a formula with no unnecessary additives. Ingredient and certification claims here are the maker stated claims on each bag.

Flock fit

Scratch and Peck Grower Crumbles

Flock size1-34-67-1213-2525+
Also suitsDucks

Scratch and Peck Starter Mash

Flock size1-34-67-1213-2525+
Also suitsDucks

Scratch and Peck Layer Crumbles

Flock size1-34-67-1213-2525+
Also suitsDucks

Scratch and Peck Grower Mash

Flock size1-34-67-1213-2525+
Also suitsDucks

FAQ for the flock

What is the difference between mash and crumbles?

Form. The mash examples here are loose whole grains you can see individually. The crumble examples are whole grains formed into small pieces. Both sides state corn and soy free recipes with USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified certifications.

Can mash chicken feed be fermented?

Both mash examples here are stated as fermentable. The Starter Mash example states it can be served dry or fermented. Neither crumble example states a fermenting option.

What protein levels do these feeds state?

The Starter Mash example states 20.5% protein, the Grower Mash and Grower Crumbles examples state 17% protein, and the Layer Crumbles example states 16% protein. Each bag also names its stage: starter, grower or layer.

Are these feeds for ducks as well as chickens?

Yes. All four examples are stated for chickens and ducks, from the starter mash for chicks and ducklings to the layer crumbles for laying chickens and ducks.

What bag sizes do the examples come in?

The two mash examples come in a 10 lb pouch. The two crumble examples come in a 25 lb bag. The Starter Mash and Layer Crumbles examples state recyclable and compostable packaging.

How the Coop Score came out

Each example is scored out of 10 on performance, build, value, safety and warranty, using only what the maker publishes. No example states a warranty. The weights are on our How We Pick page.

Product Keeper Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
Scratch and Peck Grower Crumbles 9.6 28 20 22 7 0
Scratch and Peck Starter Mash 9.6 29 20 20 7 0
Scratch and Peck Layer Crumbles 9.6 27 20 22 7 0
Scratch and Peck Grower Mash 9.5 28 20 20 7 0

Lower point totals read near 9.2 and the strongest near 9.8; because the conversion is proportional, rank by points equals rank by score.

Which should you choose?

Choose mash if you want loose whole grains, you plan to ferment some of the feed, or you are feeding the starter stage, where the Starter Mash example states 20.5% protein.

Choose crumbles if you want formed pieces, you prefer the larger 25 lb bag, or you are feeding layers, where the Layer Crumbles example is made for laying chickens and ducks.

Chicken Feed Calculator

How much feed your flock eats a day and a month, how long a bag lasts, and what it costs.

Open the calculator
Flock safety basics

Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

More coop guides

See every coop supplies guide.

More buying guides