Reusable vs Pulp Egg Cartons: Which One Should You Buy?
Four pulp egg cartons, from 25 to 250 packs, compared on reuse, humidity handling and extras for the daily backyard egg routine.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
FarmTek pulp fiber egg cartons 250 pack9.5/10View on Amazon - 2
LayHyand colored pulp egg cartons 36 pack9.4/10View on Amazon - 3
Pecking Order Paper Pulp Egg CartonsView on Amazon - 4
Paper Pulp Egg CartonsView on Amazon - 5
Blue Paper Pulp Egg CartonsView on Amazon - 6
30 Pack Vintage Egg CartonsView on Amazon - 7
Vented Paper Pulp Egg CartonsView on Amazon - 8
Economy Egg Cartons BulkView on Amazon
If you are choosing between reusable vs pulp egg cartons, start here: the pulp cartons in this guide overlap more than the labels suggest. The MT Products and AEIMIJPQ listings describe their cartons as reusable for multiple uses, while the AEIMIJPQ and Pecking Order listings describe theirs as biodegradable and compostable. So the real choice is not reusable versus pulp, it is which set fits your routine, and what to do with a carton when it wears out.
Other options for the coop
Pecking Order Paper Pulp Egg CartonsCheck price on Amazon
Paper Pulp Egg CartonsCheck price on Amazon
Blue Paper Pulp Egg CartonsCheck price on Amazon
30 Pack Vintage Egg CartonsCheck price on Amazon
Vented Paper Pulp Egg CartonsCheck price on Amazon
Economy Egg Cartons BulkCheck price on Amazon
CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.
Reusable vs pulp egg cartons: the short answer
A pulp egg carton is not a single-use item. The MT Products listing says you can use its cartons over and over again, opening and closing the lid daily, until the pulp softens or gets stained. At that point they are not trash: the AEIMIJPQ and Pecking Order listings describe their cartons as biodegradable and compostable, and the Pecking Order listings add recyclable. Rigid reusable cartons, the kind molded from plastic, are not in this comparison; everything here is paper pulp, and the listings describe reuse, recycling or composting rather than single use.
How paper pulp cartons hold up
The selling point of pulp is humidity control. The MT Products listing says the recycled pulp absorbs humidity so the eggs stay dry and fresh, and the AEIMIJPQ listing says its cartons can withstand humidity while keeping eggs safe. All four cartons hold one dozen eggs; the Pecking Order listings state small to extra large. Closures differ: the MT Products cartons close with a firm lid, the AEIMIJPQ cartons use friction-fit interlocking tabs, and the Pecking Order cartons use a latch. The AEIMIJPQ set is stackable, which keeps the egg shelf tidy.
The four cartons in this guide
Ranked by listing strength. First, the MT Products blank natural pulp carton (case of 250, 11.50 by 4.2 by 1.25 inches, made in USA): the maker says the pulp absorbs humidity, the lid fits firmly for daily opening and closing, and the blank surface takes a stamp or handwriting, which suits a farm that sells or gifts eggs at the market. Second, the AEIMIJPQ 25-pack (12 count, 11.8 by 4.3 by 2.8 inches): it ships with a sticker set and marker, and the maker says the cartons are biodegradable, compostable and stackable, which suits a small keeper who wants labels with the set. For bulk needs see our bulk egg cartons.
Third, the Pecking Order paper pulp 50-pack (12 by 4.25 by 2.75 inches): made from 100 percent reclaimed paper, holds a dozen small to extra large eggs, and is 100 percent recyclable, biodegradable and compostable. Fourth, the Pecking Order assorted-colors 50-pack (4.25 by 11.75 by 2.75 inches, 2.65 kg): the same reclaimed-paper build in assorted colors with an unfinished rustic style, which suits keepers who like color-coded cartons for different flocks. For other sizes see our full egg carton guide.
When to retire a carton
A pulp carton tells you when it is done. Cracked lids, soggy corners or a dried egg spill that will not brush off mean the carton is done, and the Pecking Order and AEIMIJPQ listings say the material is compostable. Before it reaches that point, keep it dry: pulp absorbs humidity well, but standing water will soften it. Store unused cartons stacked in a dry spot, since the AEIMIJPQ listing notes that stacking saves kitchen space.
What a dozen of your own eggs really costs, with and without startup costs, against the store price.
Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.
FAQ for the flock
How many times can I reuse a pulp egg carton?
The MT Products and AEIMIJPQ listings describe their cartons as reusable for multiple uses, so a dry carton can be refilled many times before it softens or stains.
Do pulp cartons keep eggs fresh?
The MT Products listing says the recycled pulp absorbs humidity so eggs stay dry and fresh, and the AEIMIJPQ listing says its cartons can withstand humidity while keeping eggs safe.
Are these cartons compostable?
Yes, per the listings: the AEIMIJPQ and both Pecking Order cartons are described as biodegradable and compostable.
What size eggs do they hold?
All four hold one dozen, and the Pecking Order listings state small to extra large eggs.




