Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

12 vs 18 Egg Cartons: Which One Should You Buy?

12-egg and 18-egg pulp cartons compared on count, pack size, closure and shape, with three examples from the listings reviewed.

12 vs 18 Egg Cartons: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Griwonmy Blank Pulp Egg CartonsGriwonmy Blank Pulp Egg Cartons9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2AEIMIJPQ Empty Egg Cartons 12 CountAEIMIJPQ Empty Egg Cartons 12 Count9.5/10View on Amazon
  3. 3bark and lindy Paper Pulp Egg Cartons for 18 Eggsbark and lindy Paper Pulp Egg Cartons for 18 Eggs9.3/10View on Amazon

12 vs 18 egg cartons verdict: Choose a 12-egg carton for packing a dozen eggs at a time for the kitchen, farm use or market sales. Choose an 18-egg carton for packing more eggs in each box, with the bark and lindy example offering blank cartons that take custom branding.

Morning rounds end at the nest boxes, with warm eggs in hand and a stack of empty cartons waiting by the door. The question in 12 vs 18 egg cartons is not about which box is better in general, but about how many eggs go in each box on a normal day, and which close and shape suit the trip from coop to kitchen or market.

CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

Three examples

Griwonmy Blank Pulp Egg Cartons

Griwonmy Blank Pulp Egg Cartons

Griwonmy9.6/10 Keeper Score
i
The Keeper Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 30-piece set of blank pulp trays in a 3 x 4 style, each holding 12 eggs, with a lockable lid and 6 support columns inside that wrap around each egg.

The Griwonmy example is a 3 x 4 style square tray that holds 12 normal sized eggs, sold as 30 pieces. The listing describes a lockable lid and 6 support columns inside the carton that wrap around each egg to prevent crushing, and pulp that is recyclable and compostable.

One contradiction needs noting: the bullets give a closure size of about 7.87 x 6.5 x 2.8 inches, while the spec table lists dimensions of 14.17 x 7.68 x 9.57 inches. This article trusts the bullets, so the carton size is given as 7.87 x 6.5 x 2.8 inches.

Pros

  • Lockable lid plus 6 support columns that wrap around each egg
  • 30 cartons in the set for home, market or restaurant use
  • Made from pulp, recyclable and compostable
  • Blank, unprinted trays for home or commercial use

Cons

  • No warranty term is stated
  • Care is hand wash only
  • Listed weight of 2.11 kg does not say per carton or per pack
AEIMIJPQ Empty Egg Cartons 12 Count

AEIMIJPQ Empty Egg Cartons 12 Count

AEIMIJPQ9.5/10 Keeper Score
i
The Keeper Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 25-pack of natural paper pulp cartons in a 2x6 style, each holding 12 eggs, with a sticker set and marker, a lift inside and a buckle outside.

The AEIMIJPQ example is a 25-pack of natural paper pulp cartons in a 2x6 style, each holding 12 eggs, with a sticker set and marker included. The listing describes a lift inside and a buckle outside for an easy close, friction fit interlocking tabs, and cartons that stack to save kitchen space.

The listing calls the cartons sturdy, reusable, biodegradable and compostable, and states uses from kitchen storage to farm use and transport. No warranty term is stated, and no support column count is stated.

Pros

  • 25 cartons plus a sticker set and marker in the set
  • Stackable for saving kitchen space
  • Buckle outside and friction fit interlocking tabs for a stable close
  • Biodegradable, compostable and reusable paper pulp

Cons

  • No warranty term is stated
  • Closure relies on a buckle and tabs rather than a lockable lid
  • No support column count is stated
  • Carton holds 12 eggs only, so larger daily counts need more boxes
bark and lindy Paper Pulp Egg Cartons for 18 Eggs

bark and lindy Paper Pulp Egg Cartons for 18 Eggs

bark and lindy9.3/10 Keeper Score
i
The Keeper Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 15-count set of blank paper pulp cartons, each holding 18 eggs, made from recycled paper fibers and open to custom branding.

The bark and lindy example is a set of 15 blank paper pulp cartons, each holding 18 eggs, made from recycled paper fibers. The listing gives dimensions of 14 x 13 x 8 inches and says the blank cartons take custom branding.

One contradiction needs noting: the spec table lists the material type as plastic, while the title says paper pulp and the bullets say recycled paper fibers. This article trusts the title and bullets, so the material is given as paper pulp.

Pros

  • Holds 18 eggs in each box
  • Blank cartons for adding custom branding
  • Made from recycled paper fibers
  • 15 cartons in the set

Cons

  • No closure type is stated
  • No warranty term is stated
  • Blank finish means no printed labeling is included

Other options for the coop

12 vs 18 Egg Cartons: Side by Side

Factor AEIMIJPQ example Griwonmy example bark and lindy example
Eggs per carton 12 12 18
Pack count 25 cartons, plus sticker set and marker 30 cartons 15 cartons
Style 2×6 style 3 x 4 style square tray Box
Dimensions 11.8 x 4.3 x 2.8 inches 7.87 x 6.5 x 2.8 inches 14 x 13 x 8 inches
Material Natural paper pulp Paper pulp Recycled paper fibers
Closure Buckle outside, friction fit interlocking tabs Lockable lid Not stated

Figures are as stated in the listings reviewed; where a listing states nothing, this article says so rather than filling the gap.

Count and pack size

Count is the clearest split. The two 12-egg examples hold 12 eggs per carton, while the bark and lindy example holds 18 eggs per carton. Pack sizes differ too: the Griwonmy example comes as 30 pieces, the AEIMIJPQ example as 25 cartons with a sticker set and marker, and the bark and lindy example as 15 cartons. A keeper who packs a dozen at a time gets 30 boxes from the Griwonmy pack or 25 from the AEIMIJPQ pack, while a keeper who packs 18 at a time gets 15 boxes from the bark and lindy pack.

Closures and protection

Closures separate the 12-egg examples from each other. The Griwonmy example states a lockable lid and 6 support columns inside that wrap around each egg to prevent crushing. The AEIMIJPQ example states a lift inside, a buckle outside and friction fit interlocking tabs for a stable close, with no support column count stated. The bark and lindy example states no closure type at all, so its close cannot be set against the other two.

Material and shape

All three examples are pulp cartons. The AEIMIJPQ example states natural paper pulp in a 2×6 style at 11.8 x 4.3 x 2.8 inches, the Griwonmy example states paper pulp in a 3 x 4 style square tray at about 7.87 x 6.5 x 2.8 inches, and the bark and lindy example states recycled paper fibers at 14 x 13 x 8 inches. The 2×6 style gives a longer, narrower box than the 3 x 4 tray, and the bark and lindy example lists 14 x 13 x 8 inches.

Flock fit

Griwonmy 12-Egg Trays

Flock size1-34-67-1213-2525+

AEIMIJPQ 12-Count Cartons

Flock size1-34-67-1213-2525+

bark and lindy 18-Egg Cartons

Flock size1-34-67-1213-2525+

Fitting It to Your Flock

  • Match carton count to how many eggs go in each box: 12 or 18 per carton as listed.
  • Pick the 3 x 4 square tray shape, the 2×6 style, or the 18-egg box, as listed.
  • Choose a lockable lid or a buckle close for cartons that travel to market.
  • Keep blank cartons on hand for branding with the sticker set and marker.

FAQ for the flock

Should a small flock use 12-egg or 18-egg cartons?

The 12-egg examples fit keepers who pack a dozen eggs at a time, while the 18-egg example fits keepers who pack more eggs per carton. Match the box to how many eggs go in each carton on a normal day.

Do these cartons stack?

Only the AEIMIJPQ example states that its cartons stack to save kitchen space. The other two listings state nothing about stacking, so stacking is not claimed for them.

What are these cartons made from?

Paper pulp in all three cases: natural paper pulp for the AEIMIJPQ example, paper pulp for the Griwonmy example, and recycled paper fibers for the bark and lindy example. The bark and lindy spec table lists plastic, but the title and bullets say paper pulp, and this article trusts the title and bullets.

Do the 12-egg cartons close firmly?

Yes, in different ways. The Griwonmy example states a lockable lid, and the AEIMIJPQ example states a buckle outside with friction fit interlocking tabs.

Can the blank cartons take custom branding?

Yes. The bark and lindy cartons are blank for adding custom branding, and the AEIMIJPQ set includes a sticker set and marker for labeling.

How the Coop Score came out

Each example is scored on performance, build, value, safety and warranty, using only what the listing publishes. No listing states a warranty. How we pick explains the weights.

Product Keeper Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
Griwonmy 12-Egg Trays 9.6 29 21 21 4 0
AEIMIJPQ 12-Count Cartons 9.5 28 20 21 3 0
bark and lindy 18-Egg Cartons 9.3 26 18 19 0 0

A product’s weighted total becomes its score on a scale capped at 9.8 and floored at 9.2, in a straight line.

Which should you choose?

Choose a 12-egg carton if you pack a dozen eggs at a time, you want a lockable lid or a buckle close, and you like a stackable box for the kitchen or farm use.

Choose an 18-egg carton if you pack 18 eggs per box, you want the blank cartons for custom branding that the bark and lindy example offers, and you have room to store a box of 14 x 13 x 8 inches.

Backyard Egg Cost Calculator

What a dozen of your own eggs really costs, with and without startup costs, against the store price.

Open the calculator
Flock safety basics

Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

More coop guides

See the egg handling hub, the best egg cartons guide, the best egg cartons for 18 eggs guide, and the reusable vs pulp egg cartons comparison.

More buying guides