18 vs 24 Egg Skelter: Which One Should You Buy?
An 18-egg holder suits a small flock's daily gathering, while a 24-egg skelter suits a bigger haul, so match the holder to how many eggs you bring in.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Toplife Spiral Metal Egg Skelter Dispenser Rack9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Toplife Spiral Design Stainless Steel Egg Skelter Dispenser9.5/10View on Amazon - 3
Black Metal Egg Holder Countertop9.5/10View on Amazon
The egg basket comes in full most mornings, and the fridge door fills with cartons that slide, tip and crowd the whole shelf. A dedicated egg holder keeps that daily flow tidy: the eggs stay in one place, the older ones are easy to reach, and the fridge stays organized. The 18 vs 24 egg skelter question has a short answer. An 18-egg holder suits a small flock’s daily gathering, while a 24-egg skelter suits a bigger daily haul. Match the capacity to how many eggs you bring in between trips to the kitchen, and the holder is unlikely to overflow or sit mostly empty.
CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.
18 vs 24 egg skelter: which one should you buy?
Start with a simple count. The four listings compared here each state a capacity of 18 eggs, so they represent the 18 side of the question. None of them states a 24-egg capacity, and the 2-pack listing reaches 36 eggs across its 2 trays. If you gather 18 eggs or fewer between kitchen trips, any of the four 18-egg holders below will do the job. If your daily gathering runs bigger, look for a larger skelter or run two holders side by side. The rest of this guide walks through the four 18-egg picks, ranked, so you can match lid style, care notes and size to your fridge.
The four 18-egg picks, ranked
Ranked by performance, build, value and safety, using only what each listing states.
LocknLock Eggs Dispenser (18 Eggs). The top-ranked pick. The listing states an 18-egg capacity, a patented 4-hinge locking system with a silicone sealing ring, and airtight and watertight construction. It is the only one of the four that the maker lists as microwave, freezer and top rack dishwasher safe, which makes daily cleaning simple. The stated size is 12.6 inches long, 2.8 inches wide and 7 inches high, and the stated weight is 6.4 ounces. The material is BPA-free plastic. It takes the top spot because its stated care profile is the most flexible of the four.
MesRosa Automatic Rolling Egg Holder. The listing states 18 eggs per layer, with a gentle slope that rolls eggs forward automatically and a card slot that fixes each layer for stacking. The stated size is 11.42 inches long, 9.06 inches wide and 2.76 inches high, and the stated weight is 1.3 pounds. The tray is gray, transparent, food-grade and BPA free. One caution: the listing’s spec table claims a maximum capacity of 28 eggs and different dimensions (11.2 by 8.5 inches), while the title and bullets say 18 eggs and 11.42 by 9.06 inches. The title and bullets win, so treat this one as an 18-egg holder.
LonlyEagle Covered Egg Holders, 2 Pack. The listing states 36 eggs across 2 covered trays, each tray fitting 18 eggs. The stated size is 12.6 inches by 7.1 inches by 2.7 inches, and the stated weight is 0.41 kg. The trays are clear BPA-free plastic with hinged lids, described as airtight, and they stack to save fridge space. The care note matters: the listing says to wash them with mild water and a sponge, and not to use the dishwasher. It ranks next because the 2-pack gives the most total storage of the four, with simpler care.
Ambergron 18 Eggs Holder for Refrigerator. The listing states a capacity of 18 eggs in a clear, stackable holder sized 12.2 inches by 6.5 inches by 3.1 inches high. The material is BPA-free, food-friendly plastic with an open top. The care notes conflict inside the listing: the bullets say hand wash only and not dishwasher safe, while the spec table’s special-features line says dishwasher safe. The bullets win, so plan to hand wash this one. It comes last only because its stated care profile is the most limited of the four.
Match the holder to your daily gathering
Capacity is the whole question here. All four picks state 18 eggs, so the real decision is lid style, care and fit. A keeper who brings in a modest basket each morning and cooks through the week should find 18 eggs plenty. A keeper with a bigger laying crew will want the 2-pack’s 36 eggs or a second holder. Count the eggs you gather on your busiest day, then pick the holder that covers it with room to spare.
Lids, care and cleaning
The lids tell you how the eggs ride in the fridge. The LocknLock listing claims a locking, airtight and watertight seal, and it is the only one of the four listed as dishwasher, freezer and microwave safe. The LonlyEagle trays have hinged lids described as airtight, but the listing says to wash them with mild water and a sponge and to keep them out of the dishwasher. The Ambergron holder has an open top, so it suits a fridge shelf where nothing sits on top of it, and the bullets call for hand washing. The MesRosa listing says to clean the trays with warm water and soap. Match the care note to your routine: if the holder goes in the dishwasher, the LocknLock listing is the only one of the four that allows it.
Will it fit your fridge?
Measure the shelf before you buy. The MesRosa tray is 11.42 inches long and 9.06 inches wide; the LonlyEagle trays are 12.6 by 7.1 inches; the Ambergron holder is 12.2 by 6.5 inches; the LocknLock dispenser is 12.6 inches long but only 2.8 inches wide. The LocknLock dispenser stands 7 inches tall, so it needs a tall shelf, while the other three list heights of 2.76, 2.7 and 3.1 inches. The best egg skelter guide compares countertop models if you would rather keep eggs outside the fridge.
Plastic, BPA free and food grade
All four listings are plastic, and all four state BPA free. The MesRosa listing adds food-grade material, and the Ambergron listing adds food-friendly plastic. None of the four states a warranty term, so warranty plays no part in the ranking.
What a dozen of your own eggs really costs, with and without startup costs, against the store price.
Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.
FAQ for the flock
Is an 18-egg holder enough for my flock?
It depends on your daily gathering, not your flock size. The four listings compared here each state 18 eggs, so if you bring in 18 or fewer between kitchen trips, one holder is enough. The 2-pack listing reaches 36 eggs across its 2 trays for heavier days.
What is the difference between an egg skelter and a fridge egg holder?
The listings in this guide are fridge egg holders: covered trays or auto-rolling containers made for the refrigerator. A spiral skelter is the countertop ramp style that dispenses eggs in the order they were added. The what is an egg skelter guide explains the countertop style.
Can I put these holders in the dishwasher?
Only the LocknLock listing states dishwasher safe. The LonlyEagle listing says not to use the dishwasher, the Ambergron bullets call for hand washing, and the MesRosa listing says to wash with warm water and soap.
Do the holders stack?
The MesRosa, LonlyEagle and Ambergron listings each state stacking. The MesRosa layers fix together with a card slot, the LonlyEagle trays stack, and the Ambergron holder is listed as stackable. The LocknLock listing does not state stacking.
How do I keep track of the oldest eggs?
The MesRosa listing states an auto-rolling slope that moves eggs forward as you take them, so the oldest egg sits at the front. With the covered trays, add new eggs at the back and take from the front.
More coop guides
- Egg Skelter vs Egg Basket: Which One Should You Buy?
- Spiral Egg Skelter vs Egg Carton: Which Should You Buy?
- Best Egg Collecting Basket: Wire, Wood and Apron Picks
- iDesign Clear Plastic Egg Holder Review: Pros, Cons & Who It’s For
- Toplife Spiral Metal Egg Skelter Review: Specs, Pros, Cons and Who It Suits
- What Is an Egg Skelter?
- Best Egg Skelter: Countertop Egg Holders for Fresh Eggs
See the egg handling picks and the blog for more keeper guides.




