Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Small vs Large Chick Brooder: Which One Should You Buy?

Small brooders for up to 8 chicks, large ones for up to 20, and why a heat plate beats a heat lamp, with four setups ranked on what their listings state.

Small vs Large Chick Brooder: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1JXJHOVV Large Chick Brooder Heating Plate 12 x 12 for Up toJXJHOVV Large Chick Brooder Heating Plate 12 x 12 for Up to9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2K&H Brooder PlateK&H Brooder PlateView on Amazon
  3. 3Flip Top Chick Feeder TroughFlip Top Chick Feeder TroughView on Amazon
  4. 4Hen Pen Pop-Up Deluxe Brooder for ChicksHen Pen Pop-Up Deluxe Brooder for ChicksView on Amazon
  5. 5RentACoop Chick2Chicken 5lb 2-Port Feeder and 1-Gal SmallRentACoop Chick2Chicken 5lb 2-Port Feeder and 1-Gal SmallView on Amazon
  6. 6Chick Feeder 1-Quart Capacity for All Small PoultryChick Feeder 1-Quart Capacity for All Small PoultryView on Amazon

For a first small batch of chicks, a small brooder is the right call; for a full hatch or a bigger flock, go large. The small setups here are rated for up to 8 chicks, the large ones for up to 20, and the heat source matters as much as the box: a heat plate beats a heat lamp for safety. The four setups below are ranked on what their listings state.

Other options for the coop

CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

Small vs large chick brooder: how to choose

Chick count is the first filter. The RentACoop Little Red Barn states it comfortably raises up to 8 chicks for their first 6 weeks, while the LavviTech pop-up and the Magicfly plate are both stated for up to 20 chicks. If your hatch is a dozen or more, the small barn runs out of room fast; if you are starting with a half dozen, the 45 by 45 by 20.5 inch LavviTech is a lot of empty floor to heat.

Heat is the second filter. The RentACoop set includes a 10 by 10 inch heating plate, the Magicfly is an 11 by 15 inch plate, and the GIFANK kit includes a chick heating plate. Heat plates use radiant heat the chicks gather under, which the listings frame as safer than a heat lamp, and the Magicfly adds a 12-hour auto shut-off timer and overheat protection. Heat lamps are a known coop fire risk, so plates are the safer pick wherever the listing offers one.

The four setups, ranked

1. RentACoop Little Red Barn, small complete set

The RentACoop is the only complete small set here: the foldable barn brooder, a 10 by 10 inch heating plate with a foldable anti-roost cone, a 2.5 lb chick feeder with anti-roost lid, a 64 oz chick drinker, four fitted hatchling liners for weeks 0 to 3, one fitted jute liner for 3 plus weeks, a swing and accessory stand set, an LED light with 3 color settings, a security latch and a sticker sheet. It states up to 8 chicks for their first 6 weeks, a draft-free interior, clear-view doors and non-absorbent plastic that wipes clean, at a stated 5.5 pounds. It folds flat for storage.

2. Magicfly brooder plate, heat for up to 20

The Magicfly is a heating plate, not a full brooder: a 200W smart radiant plate at 11 by 15 inches, stated for up to 20 chicks, with digital temperature control from 86 to 194 degrees F, a remote, a timer with 12-hour auto shut-off and overheat protection. It adjusts to 5 height levels, warms a stated 16-inch zone, and includes a cover that blocks droppings plus a chew-proof cord sleeve. It states use for 6 to 8 weeks until feathered and weighs a stated 2.95 pounds. Pair it with a brooder box of your own.

3. LavviTech large pop-up brooder box

The LavviTech is the roomiest box: a pop-up brooder at 45 by 45 by 20.5 inches, stated for up to 20 chicks, in 420D Oxford cloth with dual mesh doors, a removable top cover, a removable bottom pad, 3 ground spikes and a storage bag. It states a 3-second setup, indoor and outdoor use, and a stated weight of 2.71 pounds. It ships no heat source, feeder or waterer, so plan those separately.

4. GIFANK all-in-one brooder kit

The GIFANK kit bundles a foldable octagonal brooding pen in moisture-resistant PVC with a chicken heat plate, a feeder and waterer set, and 2 wooden chick perches. The listing states 5-minute tool-free assembly, an octagonal structure with no sharp edges, a feeder with 12 individual compartments, a 1.3 liter waterer with a splash-proof guard, BPA-free materials and a wipe-clean non-porous surface. It states a weight of 15.52 ounces and dimensions of 16 by 13 by 7 inches. No chick count is stated, so the guide cannot rank it on capacity.

Size, setup and cleanup

Setup effort varies. The LavviTech states a 3-second pop-up, the GIFANK states 5 minutes with no tools, and the RentACoop states tool-free assembly that sets up in minutes. The RentACoop folds flat, the LavviTech folds into a carry bag, and the GIFANK folds flat for storage in a coop or garage. On cleanup, the RentACoop states non-absorbent plastic that wipes clean, the LavviTech states a removable bottom pad and quick-dry Oxford fabric, the GIFANK states a smooth non-porous surface that wipes clean, and the Magicfly states a wipeable cover over the plate.

Brooder and heat lamp safety

Heat lamps are a common cause of coop and barn fires. If you use one, secure it with more than the clamp (a chain or wire to a fixed point), keep it well away from bedding, walls and cardboard, and plug it into an outlet or a cord rated for the load. Radiant heat plates run cooler and remove most of that risk. Check chicks often in the first days: huddling under the heat means too cold, spreading to the edges means too warm. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

FAQ for the flock

How many chicks fit in a small brooder?

The RentACoop states it comfortably raises up to 8 chicks for their first 6 weeks. If your hatch is bigger than that, start with a larger setup instead of crowding a small one.

How many chicks fit in a large brooder?

The LavviTech pop-up and the Magicfly plate are both stated for up to 20 chicks. The GIFANK kit states no chick count, so its capacity is unstated.

Heat plate or heat lamp?

Heat plates. Three of the four setups include or are a heat plate, and the listings frame plates as safer than heat lamps. Heat lamps are a known fire risk in a coop full of dust and bedding.

What size heat plate do I need?

The RentACoop includes a 10 by 10 inch plate, and the Magicfly is an 11 by 15 inch plate stated to warm a 16-inch zone for up to 20 chicks. Match the plate to your chick count and give the chicks room to move away from the heat.

Can the brooder go outside?

The LavviTech states indoor and outdoor use. The Magicfly states indoor use. The GIFANK describes indoor use in basements, storage rooms or garages and outdoor use in a shaded area. The RentACoop listing states no indoor or outdoor rating, so the guide leaves that open for it.

More coop guides

See the best brooder heater plate, brooder heater vs heat lamp, chick brooders for backyard and our brooders hub.

More buying guides