Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

6 vs 12 Egg Cartons: Which One Should You Buy?

A 6-count carton suits small lots, gifts and market display, while a 12-count carton packs a dozen eggs in one box for a buyer who wants a dozen.

6 vs 12 Egg Cartons: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1EVANCENT 100 Pack Large Egg CartonsEVANCENT 100 Pack Large Egg Cartons9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 240 Pack Half Dozen Egg Cartons Bulk 6 Count40 Pack Half Dozen Egg Cartons Bulk 6 Count9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 360 PCS Plastic Egg Cartons Bulk with Date Labels60 PCS Plastic Egg Cartons Bulk with Date Labels9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Azatemgo Half Dozen Egg Cartons 40 Pack Pulp FiberAzatemgo Half Dozen Egg Cartons 40 Pack Pulp FiberView on Amazon
  5. 550 PCS Paper Egg Cartons50 PCS Paper Egg CartonsView on Amazon
  6. 6MT Products Blank Natural Pulp Egg Cartons BulkMT Products Blank Natural Pulp Egg Cartons BulkView on Amazon
  7. 7MT Products Blank Natural Pulp Egg Cartons Holds Up to TwelveMT Products Blank Natural Pulp Egg Cartons Holds Up to TwelveView on Amazon
  8. 8Egg Cartons- Adorable Printed Design for Farm Fresh EggsEgg Cartons- Adorable Printed Design for Farm Fresh EggsView on Amazon
  9. 9250 Egg Cartons- Bulk Value Bundle- Adorable Printed Design250 Egg Cartons- Bulk Value Bundle- Adorable Printed DesignView on Amazon

At collection time, eggs pile up in the basket while cartons wait on the shelf, and the keeper must decide how to pack them for the fridge, for gifts, or for market day. The 6 vs 12 egg cartons question comes down to how many eggs go in each carton, and the answer changes with the flock, the buyer, and the trip the eggs will take. A carton that suits a family fridge may not suit a market stall, and a carton that suits a market stall may not suit a gift.

Other options for the coop

CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

6 vs 12 egg cartons: half dozens or full dozens

A 12-count carton packs a dozen eggs in a single carton, while 6-count cartons split the same eggs across cartons. That split is the whole choice. A single carton means fewer boxes to stack, carry and count, while smaller cartons mean eggs can be handed out in smaller lots, one lot at a time. Neither size is right for every keeper, because the right size follows the eggs: where they go, who takes them, and how many leave the house at once.

The listings compared here are all 6-count cartons, in packs from 24 cartons to 200 cartons, in clear plastic and in colored pulp. They show what a 6-count carton does well: a small lot for the fridge, a gift lot for a neighbor, and a display lot for a market customer who wants half a dozen. A 12-count carton does the opposite job in one box: a full dozen for a buyer who wants a dozen, with fewer cartons to handle on a busy market day.

The gear: 6-count cartons compared

The APOCHON carton is a clear PET carton in a 200 pack, holding 6 eggs in a 2×3 grid, with a snap closure and a flat top. Its bullets give a size of 5.7 x 3.9 x 2.76 inches, while its spec table gives a height of 2.5 inches. The listing states food grade material and hand wash care, and the clear walls let a buyer inspect the eggs with the lid closed, which suits market display.

The ALISWAT carton is a clear carton in a 180 pack, also holding 6 eggs in a 2×3 grid at 5.7 x 3.9 inches, made from recycled PET with a hinge closure. Its stackable shape saves fridge and pantry space, and its egg-shaped cups lock eggs in place during storage and transport. Like the APOCHON carton, it states hand wash care, and its clear walls suit market and retail display.

The FVIEXE carton is a clear plastic carton in a 100 pack, holding 6 chicken eggs at 5.7 x 3.9 x 2.5 inches, with 2 tight buckles and cone supports for a tight closure. Its listing states freezer safe material, BPA free material and hand wash care, and its flat top stacks for display in produce stands and grocery stores. It fits normal size hen eggs, and it states that it does not fit duck eggs, goose eggs or oversized hen eggs.

The LayHyand carton is a colored pulp carton in a 24 pack, holding 6 eggs at 6.1 x 4.7 x 2.9 inches, in 6 colors with a buckle clamshell closure. Its pulp material absorbs humidity, and the top of the carton has room to stamp a logo or write a message, which suits a farm identity at market. It fits normal size chicken eggs, and it states that it does not fit large chicken eggs, duck eggs or goose eggs.

When a 6-count carton wins

A 6-count carton wins when eggs leave the house in small lots. A family fridge, a gift for a neighbor, and a market customer who wants half a dozen all suit a small carton, because no eggs sit unsold in an open box. The colored pulp carton adds a gift and market angle, with colors and a top that takes a stamp or a message, while the clear plastic cartons add display, since buyers can see the eggs before buying. For keepers who sell at a market, the farmers market cartons picks cover more market options.

When a 12-count carton wins

A 12-count carton wins when a buyer wants a dozen eggs in one box. Fewer cartons mean fewer lids to close, fewer boxes to stack, and fewer boxes to count at the end of a market day. A keeper with a larger collection, or a buyer who takes a dozen at a time, gets more from one carton than from splitting eggs across cartons. The trade is flexibility: a dozen in one carton cannot be handed over as a sealed half dozen for a buyer who wants only half a dozen, while 6-count cartons can.

What to check before buying

Check egg size against the listing. Every carton here fits normal or medium hen eggs, and the LayHyand and FVIEXE listings state plainly that they do not fit large chicken eggs, duck eggs or goose eggs. Match the carton to the eggs the flock actually lays, not to the eggs in a photo, because an oversized egg will not sit right in a cup made for a normal egg. The egg carton size guide covers dimensions in more detail.

Check closure and material. The clear plastic cartons use snap, hinge or buckle closures, and the pulp carton uses a buckle clamshell closure, so the closure should match how the carton travels: stacked in a fridge, carried to market, or handed over as a gift. Clear plastic shows the eggs with the lid closed, while pulp absorbs humidity and takes a stamp or a message on top. Check pack count against need: the packs here run from a 24 pack to a 200 pack, so a small flock with a market stall on weekends needs a different pack than a keeper packing eggs every day. Check care: every listing here states hand wash care, so plan on washing by hand rather than by machine.

Flock safety basics

Wash your hands after handling birds, eggs or equipment, supervise children around the flock, and check local rules on flock size and roosters before you buy. For sick birds, call a poultry veterinarian or your state extension office. See CDC backyard poultry guidance. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

FAQ for the flock

Do 6-count cartons fit large chicken eggs?

The listings here fit normal or medium hen eggs. The LayHyand and FVIEXE listings state that they do not fit large chicken eggs, duck eggs or goose eggs, so check the listing for the eggs in question.

Which carton material shows the eggs without opening?

Clear plastic. The APOCHON, ALISWAT and FVIEXE cartons are clear, so a buyer can inspect the eggs with the lid closed, which suits market display.

Can pulp cartons be labeled for a farm market?

Yes. The LayHyand carton top has room to stamp a logo or write a message, and the APOCHON carton can be labeled to match a farm identity.

How many cartons come in the bulk packs here?

The packs here are a 200 pack, a 180 pack, a 100 pack and a 24 pack, so the pack should match how many eggs leave the house.

Are these cartons reusable?

The plastic cartons state reusable use, and the pulp carton is also listed as reusable. Every listing here states hand wash care, so wash by hand between uses.

More coop guides

See the egg handling guides and the egg carton picks.

More buying guides