Incubator vs Brooder: Which One Should You Buy?
An incubator covers the hatch stage and a brooder covers the raise stage; this guide explains each role and ranks four brooder picks from the listings.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Brinsea Ecoglow Safety 600 Chick or Duckling Brooder9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Brinsea Ecoglow Safety 1200 Chick or Duckling BrooderView on Amazon - 3
RentACoop Little Red Barn Chick Brooder Set Complete brooderView on Amazon - 4
RentACoop Little Red Barn Chick Brooder DurableView on Amazon - 5
A&I Brooders and Incubators CURADLE RCOM Large PET BrooderView on Amazon - 6
Brooder Heater for ChicksView on Amazon - 7
40 Quail Egg Incubator with Automatic Egg Turning HumidityView on Amazon
You clean out the nest boxes and find a full clutch, and the question lands: do you hatch them yourself or wait for a broody hen? The incubator vs brooder decision is simpler than it sounds. An incubator covers the hatch stage, holding eggs warm until they hatch. A brooder covers the raise stage, giving newly hatched chicks a warm, draft-free home with heat, feed and water. You need the first only if you hatch eggs; you need the second for every batch of chicks you raise, unless a broody hen raises them for you.
Other options for the coop
Brinsea Ecoglow Safety 1200 Chick or Duckling BrooderCheck price on Amazon
RentACoop Little Red Barn Chick Brooder Set Complete brooderCheck price on Amazon
RentACoop Little Red Barn Chick Brooder DurableCheck price on Amazon
A&I Brooders and Incubators CURADLE RCOM Large PET BrooderCheck price on Amazon
Brooder Heater for ChicksCheck price on Amazon
40 Quail Egg Incubator with Automatic Egg Turning HumidityCheck price on Amazon
CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.
Incubator vs brooder: what each one does
An incubator is an egg box with a job: it holds eggs warm until they hatch: the hatch stage. Once chicks are out and fluffed, the incubator’s job is done, and moving day comes fast. A brooder is the raise stage: a warm, draft-free space where hatched chicks live for their first weeks, with a heat source they can move toward or away from, plus a feeder and a waterer. The RentACoop listings describe the pattern well: their brooders raise chicks for the first 6 weeks, with hatchling liners for 0 to 3 weeks and a jute liner for 3+ weeks, which matches the raise stage the brooder covers.
Do you need both?
It depends on where your chicks come from. If you buy day-old chicks, you need only a brooder. If you hatch your own eggs in an incubator, you need a brooder ready before the first pip, because chicks move to it once they are dry. If a broody hen does the hatching, she handles both stages herself, and our incubator vs broody hen comparison covers that choice. Most backyard keepers who hatch at home end up owning both: the incubator for the hatch stage and the brooder for the raise stage.
What a good brooder has
The listings agree on the parts that matter. Heat comes first: a radiant heat plate the chicks gather under, like the 18-watt Brinsea Ecoglow plate or the 10 inch by 10 inch plate in the RentACoop set, or thermostat-regulated heaters like the 125-watt units on each level of the Hatching Time 3-layer brooder. Heat plates beat heat lamps on fire risk: the Brinsea listing states low-voltage operation and no hot spots, and our site’s standing rule is to recommend heat plates over lamps around bedding. The brooder body should be draft-free but easy to clean: the RentACoop brooders are foldable plastic that wipes clean and folds flat for storage, and the Hatching Time unit is PP polypropylene with removable floor mats above deep waste trays. Feed and water should be built in or easy to mount: the RentACoop set includes a 2.5 lb feeder and a 64 oz drinker, and the Hatching Time brooder has a top-mounted tank that gravity feeds water to adjustable drinkers on each level. A secure lid or latch matters if you have cats, kids or curious dogs: the RentACoop brooders include a security latch.
The four brooder picks, ranked
All four products in our data are brooders, so this gear section covers the raise stage of the incubator vs brooder question. They rank by stated specs, safety features and warranty.
1. Brinsea Ecoglow Safety 1200: the plate to build around
The Brinsea is a radiant brooder heat plate for up to 35 newly hatched chicks or 20 older chicks, and it tops the ranking on the strongest stated specs here. It runs at 18 watts on low voltage, which the listing presents as the safer alternative to mains-voltage plates and heat lamps, with a stated 3-year warranty subject to registration. It has adjustable screw-on legs, an indicator light and a 10-foot power cord, and the listing states indoor use with the room not dropping below 50°F. Note the honesty of the listing: 35 chicks is for newborns, 20 for older ones. It is a plate only, so you pair it with your own brooder box, feeder and waterer.
2. Hatching Time 3-layer brooder: for quail and small game birds
The Hatching Time unit is a 3-section, 3-layer brooder box for quail, pheasant, partridge and other small chicks under 5 inches tall, with a stated 1-year manufacturer warranty. Each level has its own 125-watt heater with a thermostat regulating 68°F to 104°F, designed for indoor rooms warmer than 65°F. Feeding and watering are built in: a top-mounted tank gravity feeds adjustable drinkers, and starter feeders with feed-loss grills sit on each level. It measures 38.6 by 23.6 by 49.8 inches and weighs 81 lb, assembly is required, and the three lightbulbs are sold separately. It is the specialist pick: overkill for a dozen chicks, right-sized for game birds.
3. RentACoop Little Red Barn complete set: the all-in-one
The complete set folds out into a brooder that raises up to 8 chicks for their first 6 weeks, with everything in the box: the brooder, a 10 inch by 10 inch heating plate with an anti-roost cone, a 2.5 lb feeder, a 64 oz drinker, hatchling and jute liners, an LED light with 3 color settings and a security latch. The listing states no warranty term, which keeps it below the two warranted picks. It is the easiest start: tool-free setup, clear-view doors, and it folds flat when the chicks move out.
4. RentACoop Little Red Barn brooder: the shell without the kit
The standalone brooder is the same foldable plastic body, sized 32 by 17 by 20 inches and 8 lb, for up to 10 or more chicks for their first 6 weeks, with the LED light, liners and security latch, but no heat plate, feeder or waterer. The listing states no warranty term. Buy this one if you already own a heat plate like the Brinsea and want the housing to go with it; see our small vs large chick brooder guide to check the size against your flock plan.
Pick a species and a set date for candling days, lockdown and hatch day, with a calendar file to save.
Heat lamps are a common cause of coop and barn fires. If you use one, secure it with more than the clamp (a chain or wire to a fixed point), keep it well away from bedding, walls and cardboard, and plug it into an outlet or a cord rated for the load. Radiant heat plates run cooler and remove most of that risk. Check chicks often in the first days: huddling under the heat means too cold, spreading to the edges means too warm. Read our Safety Disclaimer.
FAQ for the flock
Can I use an incubator as a brooder?
No. An incubator is built for the hatch stage: it holds eggs, not chicks. Once chicks hatch, they need the raise stage setup: a draft-free brooder with a heat source, a feeder and a waterer, like the four picks above.
How long do chicks stay in a brooder?
It varies by setup. The RentACoop listings state their brooders raise chicks for the first 6 weeks, with hatchling liners for 0 to 3 weeks and a jute liner for 3+ weeks.
Is a heat plate or a heat lamp better for a brooder?
A heat plate. The Brinsea listing states low-voltage radiant heat with no hot spots, and our site’s rule is to recommend plates over lamps because heat lamps are a known fire risk around bedding.
What size brooder do I need?
Match the listing’s chick count to your batch: up to 8 in the RentACoop complete set, up to 10 or more in the standalone brooder, up to 35 newborns under the Brinsea plate, or the 3-layer Hatching Time unit for small game birds under 5 inches tall.
Do brooder listings usually include a warranty?
Some do. The Brinsea states a 3-year warranty subject to registration and the Hatching Time a 1-year manufacturer warranty. The two RentACoop listings state no warranty term.
More coop guides
- Incubator vs Broody Hen: Which One Should You Buy?
- Small vs Large Chick Brooder: Which One Should You Buy?
- Indoor vs Outdoor Chicken Brooder: Which One Should You Buy?
- Plastic vs Wooden Chick Brooder (2026): 4 Compared
- Hygrometer vs Thermometer for Incubator: Which One Should You Buy?
- Best Incubator Thermostat (2026): 4 Picks
- Best Brooder for 25 Chicks (2026): 5 Setups Compared
See the incubators and hatching hub and the brooder picks.




