Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Wood vs Metal Chick Brooder: Which One Should You Buy?

Two wood brooder kits and a fabric brooder compared: sizes, heat control and included gear for raising chicks.

Wood vs Metal Chick Brooder: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Woods 0167 10.5-Inch Brooder Clamp Lamp with Bulb GuardWoods 0167 10.5-Inch Brooder Clamp Lamp with Bulb Guard9.5/10View on Amazon
  2. 2PETSFIT Baby Chick Roosting BarPETSFIT Baby Chick Roosting BarView on Amazon
  3. 3Natural Wood Chick Perch for BrooderNatural Wood Chick Perch for BrooderView on Amazon
  4. 4Wooden Chick Brooder Box with Heat Lamp and ThermometerWooden Chick Brooder Box with Heat Lamp and ThermometerView on Amazon
  5. 5Wooden Chicken BrooderWooden Chicken BrooderView on Amazon
  6. 6Chick Roosting Bar for BrooderChick Roosting Bar for BrooderView on Amazon
  7. 7Brinsea Ecoglow Safety 1200 Chick or Duckling BrooderBrinsea Ecoglow Safety 1200 Chick or Duckling BrooderView on Amazon

Picking between a wood vs metal chick brooder comes down to what is actually on the market in these listings: two solid-wood brooder kits and one fabric brooder, with no metal brooder among them. The wood kits arrive with heat lamps and feeding gear, while the fabric one folds away and moves indoors or out. This guide compares all three on size, heat control and included gear, so you can match the brooder to your chick count and your daily routine. Each pick is described from what its Amazon listing states.

Other options for the coop

CoopKeeperHQ earns a commission if you buy through our links, at no added cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.

What the two wood brooders offer

The LIAQICHA and the Nalwort are both solid-wood brooder boxes with acrylic or clear viewing windows and all-in-one kits. The LIAQICHA is tung wood with a high-transparency acrylic panel and an operable skylight, sized 31.5 by 15.8 by 15.8 inches, and it states no paint on the wood. The Nalwort is natural pine with no paint or coatings, sized 31.5 by 15.75 by 15.75 inches and weighing 22 pounds, with a skylight for ventilation and a clear observation window.

Both ship as kits. The LIAQICHA includes a chick feeder, a thermograph, one heating lamp, one lighting lamp, two bulb bases, a waterer, five bedding pads and a cleaning tool set. The Nalwort is a 20-piece kit with heat lamps, a thermometer, a waterer, a feeder, pee pads, a moisture-resistant pad and cleaning tools. Note the LIAQICHA spec table lists 33 by 17 by 4.3 inches while the bullets state 31.5 by 15.8 by 15.8 inches; trust the bullets, not the table.

Heat control and watching the chicks

Heat is the job of a brooder, and the listings differ. The LIAQICHA states an adjustable range of 0 to 120°F with a 110V-50W heat lamp that preheats the brooder in 8 seconds. The Nalwort ships two ceramic heat lamps and one illumination lamp for day-and-night viewing, but notes that a temperature controller is not included. The Phoncoo states no heat source at all, so it suits a setup where you add your own. For the heat source itself, our heat plate vs heat lamp guide compares the options, and a brooder thermometer keeps the temperature honest.

The fabric alternative

The Phoncoo is the outlier: 600D Oxford fabric over PVC pipes, 23.6 by 23.6 by 62.9 inches and 9.46 pounds, with a removable roof and floor, zipper doors and mesh panels for airflow. It holds 30 to 35 chicks and states indoor and outdoor use, with four ground stakes for outdoor stability. The fabric resists tears, repels water and wipes clean, per the maker. It is the only one of the three that folds down and moves outside, and the only one without wood.

How to choose: wood vs metal chick brooder

Ranked by what the listings state, the Nalwort leads: a 20-piece natural-pine kit for up to 35 chicks with two ceramic heat lamps, at 31.5 by 15.75 by 15.75 inches and 22 pounds. The LIAQICHA follows: a tung-wood all-in-one kit with 0 to 120°F adjustable heat, a 50W lamp that preheats in 8 seconds, five pads and a feeder and waterer, at 31.5 by 15.8 by 15.8 inches. The Phoncoo comes third: the largest of the three at 23.6 by 23.6 by 62.9 inches for 30 to 35 chicks, fabric over PVC, indoor and outdoor use, but no stated heat source and no feeder or waterer. For more designs, see our chick brooder designs.

Sizing to your chick count

The Nalwort states room for up to 35 chicks and the Phoncoo for 30 to 35, while the LIAQICHA states no chick count. The Nalwort and the Phoncoo both state room for 30 or more chicks; the LIAQICHA states no chick count. Give chicks room to move away from the heat as well as toward it, and keep the brooder where you will see it every day.

Brooder and heat lamp safety

Heat lamps are a common cause of coop and barn fires. If you use one, secure it with more than the clamp (a chain or wire to a fixed point), keep it well away from bedding, walls and cardboard, and plug it into an outlet or a cord rated for the load. Radiant heat plates run cooler and remove most of that risk. Check chicks often in the first days: huddling under the heat means too cold, spreading to the edges means too warm. Read our Safety Disclaimer.

Chicken Coop Size Calculator

Birds, breed size, run time and climate in; coop floor, run space, roost length and nesting boxes out.

Open the calculator

FAQ for the flock

Which brooder fits the most chicks?

The Nalwort states room for up to 35 chicks and the Phoncoo states 30 to 35. The LIAQICHA states no chick count.

Do any of these include heat?

The LIAQICHA includes a 110V-50W heat lamp with 0 to 120°F adjustable heat. The Nalwort includes two ceramic heat lamps and one illumination lamp, but no temperature controller. The Phoncoo states no heat source.

Which are all-in-one kits?

The LIAQICHA ships with a feeder, waterer, five pads, lamps and cleaning tools. The Nalwort is a 20-piece kit with heat lamps, a thermometer, a waterer, a feeder and pads. The Phoncoo ships the box, PVC tubes and four ground stakes, with no heat source, feeder or waterer stated.

Are any of these for outdoor use?

The Phoncoo states indoor and outdoor use with four ground stakes. The LIAQICHA and Nalwort state indoor use.

Which have a viewing window?

The LIAQICHA has an acrylic skylight and the Nalwort has a clear observation window. The Phoncoo has mesh panels for viewing and airflow.

More coop guides

See the brooder guides and the coop supply picks.

More buying guides